By Dave Wolfe

Who makes the best push cart?  Which one has the features I want? Which one is the lightest? Will a cart work with my cart and my carry bag? How many steps does it take to fold and unfold? Are there differences in the brakes? Is one cart more stable than another? Which is the easiest cart to push?

That’s a whole bunch of questions.  

With that many questions, deciding which cart to buy can be a difficult task. But we have the answer:  The most comprehensive head-to-head test ever (seriously) done on push carts has been completed. We have done the testing. We’ve collected the data. We’ve compiled the values, and we know which cart is the #MostWanted.  

Golf’s Most Wanted Push Cart: The Contestants

Most Wanted Group Unfolded

 

Notable Push Cart Features

CartFeatureTable

 

How We Tested

Comparative scoring was calculated based upon ten measured characteristics that fall under two general headings: Portability and Playability. Totals for each cart were then determined and the carts ranked on an overall 100 point scale to determine the Golf’s Most Wanted Push Cart. Here are the details of how each category was assessed and scored.

Portability Scoring

portability-scoring

Most Wanted Cart Group Folded

32

For a push cart to be an effective tool for the golfer, it must meet the golfer’s needs going to and from the course as well as on the course. While some may have the option of leaving their bag, and cart in a locker at their club, many golfers must transport the cart along with their bag. As such, Portability, is a key push cart component. To measure portability, we assessed the following three features.

The weight of each cart was measured directly using a digital spring scale. Carts were then ranked, and scored on a ten point scale from lightest to heaviest.
The folded volume was calculated for each cart. Measurements were taken to the furthest protrusion in length, width, and height directions. Carts were then sorted by volume, and scored on a ten-point scale based upon their relationship to the smallest volume cart.
The steps to unfold a cart to “play-ready” configuration were identified for each cart. Carts were then ranked from fewest to most steps, and that ranking was then translated into the ten-point scale for the category.

Playability Scoring

playability-scoring

Cart Consoles

Cart Testing Photos-3Cart Testing Photos-7

For a push cart to be Golf’s Most Wanted, it must perform on the golf course. Golfers want a cart that is easy to push, holds their bag securely, stays put when the brake is on, and has enough storage to hold their gear during play. We tested these features and more. Here is how we scored the various Playability components.


Features for each cart’s console were tallied and ranked based upon abundance and access. We recorded the number of ball holders, tee holders, cup holders, scorecard holders, and yes, pencil holders. Consoles were also scored for storage volume and ease of access. If a cart had additional storage, like a cargo net or additional cargo bag, those features were also part of the console score. Carts were ranked, and then the ranking converted to the ten-point scoring system.

Both cart and carry bags were used to assess the fit of golf bags into the different carts. For the cart bag, we used the Wilson Staff Ionix cart bag. The carry bag used was the PING Hoofer. Carts were scored based upon how secure the bag remained while traveling the terrain one would encounter during play. Points were deducted if the bag twisted, or slipped from the straps.

Straps were assessed based upon ease of adjustment and range of adjustment. How well the straps secured the bad was also assessed using the digital spring scale.

To assess the force needed to get the cart rolling, the carts were outfitted with the PING Hoofer bag, again with a full complement of golf gear and clubs. Once the bag was secure, the pounds of force needed to get the cart moving was measured. Five measurements were taken for each cart, with the average pounds of force for those measurements used as the final score for the cart.

Front wheels of the carts were positioned at the same spot on a level concrete surface for each cart and each repetition. Concrete was used for the roll tests to minimize the effect of changing grass and underlying dirt conditions as the test progressed from cart to cart.


The force to overcome the brake was assessed in the same way as the force to start rolling. The difference was that this time the force was measured with the brake engaged. If necessary, carts were rolled until the brake engaged prior to measurements being taken.

The stability score is based upon two measured components. For these measurements, carts were again equipped with the fully loaded Wilson Staff Ionix cart bag. Lateral stability was measured by recording the force needed to tip the cart sideways such that the rear wheel would lift off of the ground. The spring scale was anchored to the bag at the same position each time, with the force then applied at 90° to the bag.

The second stability measurement was recorded by hooking the digital scale to the handle and pulling straight down. Each cart was assessed for how much force was needed to lift the front wheel off the ground.

Cart maneuverability was scored based upon how well the cart performed over our test course. For this test, the carts were fitted with the Wilson Staff Ionix bag, containing a full set of fourteen clubs, a rangefinder, a dozen balls, two gloves, a towel, and a bag of tees and markers. Push handles were adjusted to the same height relative to the tester (i.e. navel height). Carts were assessed for ease of roll over various terrains and topographies. Points were deducted when a cart had difficulties turning, lost traction, or started to tip on slopes.

Golf’s Most Wanted Push Cart: The Results

Cart-Data-Table2

Golf’s Most Wanted Push Cart Winner

Bagboy Tri-Swivel 2

mwpc-1st-place-final

Golf’s Most Wanted Push Cart Runner-Up

Clicgear 3.5+

mwpc-2nd-place-final

Bagboy C3

lightest-cart-final

Big Max Blade

small-trunk-final