INDEPENDENT & UNBIASED
MyGolfSpy accepts $0 advertising dollars from any of the major golf manufacturers. We believe in always putting #ConsumerFirst.
10
Hours
Researched
2
Experts
Interviewed
15
Products
Considered
35.6m
Readers
2018 BALL RETRIEVER BUYER’S GUIDE
What if we told you that we could save you money playing golf?
According to CNN and Golf.com, 300 million golf balls are lost every year in the United States alone. On average, golfers lose 1.3 balls per round. The average golfer plays 23 rounds per year. That’s 29.9 lost golf balls per golfer. If you’re playing Titleist Pro V1s, that’s $124 annually on golf balls alone. That’s not a massive amount of money for one season, but over a decade or a lifetime, it adds up to a big chunk of change.
While it elicits its fair share of eye-rolls, the numbers suggest that a ball retriever is a sound investment. There are likely dozens of models on the market, but some designs are inarguably superior. Some have a scoop design where others have a clip mechanism to secure the ball. They vary in size; and in this case, size really does matter!
If you’re in need of a quality ball retriever, and that’s most of us – this guide is for you.
2018 Ball Retriever Features Chart
| Name | Distance Covered | Weight | Retracted Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| Callaway 15FT | 15 FT | 1.5 lb | 4 FT |
| I Gotcha 14 FT | 14 FT | 1.1 lb | 20.5 Inch |
| JP Lann 9 FT | 9 FT | 0.6 lb | 4 FT |
| Olimar 15 FT | 15 FT | 1.1 lb | 4 FT |
| Pro Active 15 FT | 15 FT | 1.2 lb | 4 FT |
| Samyo Portable Retreiver | 9 FT | 0.4 lb | 20 Inch |
| Search N Rescue Blue Rescue | 14 FT | 1.7 lb | 4 FT |
| Search N Rescue Magic Gripper | 14 FT | 1.2 lb | 24 Inch |
| Search N Rescue Orange Trapper | 9 FT | 0.5 lb | 22 Inch |
| Signstek Scoop Pick Up | 9 FT | 0.4 lb | 20 Inch |
FEATURES THAT MATTER
Ball Security: You can’t retrieve it if you can’t secure it. The ones that have a scoop design work best for soft mud, but the ball can fall out when turning upside down. Well-designed options like the I Gotcha excel at securing the ball, but sometimes struggle if the ground is soft.
Shaft Length: Size does matter because if you have a ball retriever that is too short, you won’t be able to reach balls that travel deeper into hazards. Granted you might not be able to reach the one that is in the middle of the lake, but the longer the shaft, the greater the chance you have at retrieving your ball.
Handle: When retrieving your golf ball, you want to be able to do so without getting pain or imprints from the handle. Once extended, some models get heavy and dig into your palms. We noted that the Search N Rescue Magic Gripper features an especially comfortable handle.
Sturdiness: When extended to full length, does the ball retriever droop or even snap? Some models like the I Gotcha are made from sturdier materials and hold their posture. Products that are lightweight tend to bend more and are less durable than ones that are slightly heavier like the Samyo.
HOW WE SCORE
We’re always fine-tuning the process to make sure we’re collecting the best data possible. Continuing that trend we’ve updated and refined this year’s analysis to bring you the best buying advice to improve your game.
We put in hours of testing, utilizing data-driven protocols to test new metrics.
Over the course of the test, we used the same protocol for every ball retriever in the test. To limit bias, we paid careful attention to the phrasing of the questions as well as the timing of when particular questions were asked.
Extension (25) – Does size really matter? Within this test, it does! The goal of a ball retriever is to collect you ball that has finished in any kind of water. Some retrievers have a shorter reach than others which can hinder your ability to reach your ball. The bigger the pond, the bigger your ball retriever needs to be.
Ball security (35) – After locating your stray shot, the next task would is to retrieve the ball. You want a retriever that holds your golf ball securely and can keep it secure until it reaches dry land. Not all products do this as well as they claim.
Sturdiness (30) – When extending the retriever, gravity tends to take a toll which can cause the retriever to bend and in some cases snap. Some retrievers use sturdier materials which hold their shape when extended. Products that are lightweight tend to bend more and are less durable than ones that are slightly heavier.
Handle (5) – The handle might not seem important to retrieving a golf ball, but it plays into effect more than you might think. A handle must be comfortable once retrieving the ball because all the weight is at both ends and can dig into the palm of the individual using it.
Storage (5) – In some cases, carrying a retriever is like carrying an extra club. Some are the same length as your driver, while compact models are the size of your forearm. The retrievers that performed well in this category are the ones that fold down to the smallest size possible. The ones that did not perform as well tend to be the same length as a driver and took up space.
Final grades were awarded based on total scores. Best Overall is our highest overall scoring the best ball retriever, and awards are awarded to the top three retrievers.
THE BEST BALL RETRIEVER OF 2018
I Gotcha 14 FT
"BEST BALL RETRIEVER 2018"
|
Extension
|
3rd |
|
Ball Security
|
1st |
|
Sturdiness
|
5th |
|
Handle
|
1st |
|
Storage
|
4th |
|
Total
|
85 |
Shop & Support
When you shop online consider using our special link. It helps support this site and other golfers around the world. #ConsumerFirst
What We Liked
Our “Best Ball Retriever of 2018”, the I Gotcha features a patented spring release design that tightly secures the ball for easy transport to dry land. The model tested has a 14′ reach (other lengths available) allowing you go deep in the hazard. The I Gotcha doesn’t droop when fully extended, yet still collapses to a 20.5″ when not in use.
Pros
- 14-foot reach
- Sturdy when extended
- Great for ball security
- Folds down very small for easy storage
Cons
- Might be harder to collect the ball in soft or muddy conditions.
Search N Rescue Magic Gripper
|
Extension
|
6th |
|
Ball Security
|
2nd |
|
Sturdiness
|
2nd |
|
Handle
|
1st |
|
Storage
|
4th |
|
Total
|
84 |
Shop & Support
When you shop online consider using our special link. It helps support this site and other golfers around the world. #ConsumerFirst
What We Liked
Yet another great ball retriever that delivers what it promises. The Magic Gripper might not look like your traditional retriever, but it gets the job done. The single ring collector is sized perfectly to create enough friction that golf ball stays securely within the ring. Droops less than others when fully extended.
Pros
- Once the ball is trapped, it stays trapped
- Compact when fully collapsed
- Multiple length options available
Cons
- Harsher conditions make picking up ball more difficult
Search N Rescue Blue Rescue
|
Extension
|
3rd |
|
Ball Security
|
3rd |
|
Sturdiness
|
5th |
|
Handle
|
1st |
|
Storage
|
7th |
|
Total
|
79 |
Shop & Support
When you shop online consider using our special link. It helps support this site and other golfers around the world. #ConsumerFirst
What We Liked
A bit like a pair of tongs, the Search N Rescue Blue allows golf balls to be grabbed with ease in all conditions. Balls can sometimes come loose during transport (especially when tilted upsidedown). Be quick about it, however, and you shouldn’t have any issues.
Pros
- Great design for retrieving the ball from water
- Easy to use
- Strong when extended
Cons
- Roughly the same length as your diver when fully retracted
2018 Ball Retriever Buyers Guide
GET FIT FOR YOUR GAME WITH TRUEGOLFFIT™
Unbiased. No Guesswork. All Major Brands. Matched To Your Swing. Advanced Golf Analytics matches the perfect clubs to your exact swing using connected data and machine learning.
SEE MY RESULTS
Jim Neuendorf
11 months agoNot that I need more golf bolls 🙂 Ive used various retrievers. My favorite is the Search N Rescue.. HOWEVER, the lever popped off of mine and I could not find it.. NOR could I find a way to replace it without having to BUY another Search N Rescue. Would be nice to just be able to get a replacement part as these are expensive retrievers.
scott
1 year agoI had the old style ball retriever work fine for more than 35 years until I left at 13th hole and someone kept it for them self . The handle was replaced by a roll of green electrical tape if you see a scum sucking butt sniffing golfer who probably cheats on his score using the described retriever it let me know because i’ll be retrieving his balls . thanks
Oliver
1 year agoImagine you fall in love with somebody and then you find out that she/he has goz a ball retriever in the bag …
Fozcycle
1 year agoI use the I gotcha and routinely collect over 6 dozen balls each week. When they wear out and break, I call them and they send a new one.
David
5 months agoThat’s what my original question was, what is the telephone # to talk to someone at I GOTCHA. I need a replacement part. Thanks
Steve S
1 year agoAt first I thought I was in a time warp and it was April Fools day….really?
Brandon
1 year agoI use my 3 iron.
Don
1 year agoSo, you going to review iron covers next? 😀
boggey55
1 year agoI own an “I Gotcha” retriever. I’ve had several of them through the years. It picks of balls better than any other I’ve owned. The Magic Gripper looks like a good retriever as well.
P.J.
1 year agoI previously used the “I Gotcha”, but found when trying to pick balls out of bushes or past thick weeds, they’d catch on the spring loaded clip and I’d have to pull it out, reset it, and try again.
This year I switched to the “Magic Gripper” and have really pleased with how well it does. It doesn’t look like it would work very well – but it’s really a pretty amazing ball retriever. When collapsed back down, it’s a perfect size to sit in a side pocket of my golf bag. I also highly recommend this one!
JimmyTim
1 year agoBelieve it or not, at our last club championship, the tournament officials decided to count ball retrievers as one of the 14 clubs in the bag.
Several players were asked to remove the retrievers from their bags before starting play or be penalized for having too many clubs. Go figure!
scott
1 year agoYou should tell them if I have to remove my retriever then no golf carts they need to walk the course and no range finder you need to use the same type golf ball, no pencil with eraser no oversize ball marker ….NO CELLPHONES watch them cry or say the ball retriever is consider not a club
chrisk
1 year agoOK, now i need a review on the best replacement grip on the retriever. I’ve noticed mine tend to wear out awfully quickly 🙂
scott
1 year agoFor $2.50 you can buy a roll of electrical tape start about six inches from the end start rapping in the same spot until you get a knob then rap down to the end.
Rob
1 year agoI believe he was speaking tongue in cheek. It’s an old joke …”How can you tell someone’s a hacker?…..He gets his ball retriever regripped twice a year”
Tony
1 year agoI’ve used the Callaway ball retriever for years – works well for me and never had an issue picking up the ball. telescoping issues or rust. I did lose the cover for it – but that’s not unusual for me.
Ruben Acosta
8 months agoI’ve had a Calloway for 5 years. I had to replace it after 3 because my bag tipped over in a hallway and hit the wall and broke at the pickup. This was the best retriever I’ve had for 38 years so I bought another. I agree with another comment about being able to buy replacement parts, it should be cheaper than $38 purchase price.
Emery
1 year agoHaving BOTH the I Gotcha and Search N Rescue Magic Gripper, You got it wrong MYGOLFSPY. Both work but I have two broken I Gotcha’s as the telescoping WILL fall apart when very tiny shims break/corrode…..not to mention, when the plastic ball retrieval hoops constantly separate. (I do like the function) The Search N Rescue was 1) cheaper/longer 2) NOTICEABLY more durable (feels like a weapon! hefty) 3) Holding up perfect after a year of use (my son and I like to “go fishing” and I have a steady supply of free ProV1’s year ’round)
Dave
1 year agoI’ve also had both the I Gotcha and the Magic Gripper. The plastic pieces on the I Gotcha break easily – and its fairly expensive. The all metal construction of the Search n Rescue products is key.
Mrfood
1 year agoI gotcha will send you a replacement head fo about $10
Plaidjacket
1 year agoNice write-up.
This review hit me by surprise and I was interested to read through it. I have a Gotcha and have used it for years. It’s not perfect but 99% of the time when I need it to retrieve someone else’s ball it works well. I also like that it collapses rather short and fits in the long side pocket in my bag.
Kenny B
1 year agoI agree. I won an IGotcha maybe 10 years ago at a tournament. It’s the short 10 foot version. I wish it were a little longer, but I love how it fits in a pocket. I can judge how far is too far, so I only go after balls that are easily reached.
Tiger168
1 year agoGreat article, as always.
I would add that another significant test will be the reliability of the said gadget. I have been a long owner of a few “I GOTCHA 14 FT”, at $45 a piece (used to be around $25 retail, I meant WOW, like another private equity got a hold of this company and jack up the price or what?), and I finally gave up since it breaks down a lot. The quality is bad, the extension parts will fall apart and became loose in a few uses, it is not water friendly as any water residuals will result accelerate its demise. The spring will break or loose; the inner plastic ring will fall out easily… All and all, very poor quality at an unreasonably high price.
There are quite a few classic out there that have better price-performance ratio, IMHO.
I have switched to the following retriever and never had to look back. It was OEM by Callaway a few years back, but, I guess the relationship did not continue.
https://www.amazon.com/ProActive-Sports-Super-Lite-Lightweight-Fiberglass/dp/B079RSH72M
Robin
1 year agoYou must be bored.
Harry Nodwell
1 year agoTell us what you want to be tested in next years Buyers Guide
Tim J
1 year agoGolf Balls?
Tim J
1 year agoIs someone paying you guys not to test golf balls?
The materials inside? Whats in there? When they are cut in half, some are speckled. The cheaper ones especially. What’s up with that material? Which are cast urethane or not? Price on each? Durability of the covers? Uniformity among them..
Maybe just line them all up. Compare the 40 yard wedge shot. Try them off the driver, just for giggles, I know they supposedly all do the same thing off the driver, but lets see it again.
Here’s something I’ve always wondered: are all of them perfectly round? There’s a guy on Instagram who cuts golf balls in half (golf ball guts). One of the Chrome softs he cut in half had core that was wayy off center. If Im paying $44 for a case of balls, I’d love to know the cores are all centered. Bryson D floats his Bridgestone balls in an epsom salt solution to test roundness. Does he know something we don’t ?
Or, review tees and golf ball washer brands next.
Steve S
1 year agoAgree with others. Balls. Retrievers, ball markers, divot tools, towels, head covers, etc. have no business being reviewed here, IMO.
Brandon
1 year agoI’d like to see a shaft comparison. It would be cool to see how stock offerings from the OEM’s compare to the high end stuff.
Wayne Patton
1 year agoYou picked a good one IF you only consider the circular ones. The problem with the circular ones, however, is that you have to exactly place the circle on the ball. If you are slightly off, either left to right or front to back, you just stir up the bottom and are hosed. I have used your #1 pick and in my opinion, the Search and Rescue 2 ball retriever is vastly superior. It has a rectangular cage wide enough for 2 balls. You just put it on the bottom on the far side of the ball and pull toward you. It automatically locks the ball in. MUCH, MUCH easier and more foolproof than any of yours. Try one or ask around – you will never go back to a round retriever!!
Harry Nodwell
1 year agoThe one you are referring is similar to Blue Rescue that finished third and I agree that it worked very well. The only problem we found is that when storing it in your golf bag, it takes up a lot of room when it retracts and folds down to the size of a driver.
Jim Jaworski
1 year agoToo bad you did not test the Golden Golf Ball Retriever.
I used one for years when I was hawking balls at a nearby public course in Western New York. It was a no brainer in all conditions.
Matthew M
1 year agoI use the Search N Rescue Blue and it’s great. As stated in the review, very good at getting balls out of the water, which is where most of my lost balls end up. It is long though. Needs it’s own slot instead of fitting in a pocket.
DrMJG
1 year agoI still have a ball retriever I purchased in about 1970. With care, these last a lifetime. Unextended, it is, in fact, the longest “club” in my bag. I am not sure how much it has saved me in my lifetime, as I go fishing only for balls that are known to be mine. Yea, we look silly using one, but now that I am retired, money is money. If you want to save money, look around at garage sales and inspect before you buy.
Berniez40
1 year agoNice review!—Still the only club that ever pays for itself.
Matthew M
1 year agoI have the S&R Blue Rescue and I think it’s great. As mentioned in the review, great at getting balls out of the water, which is where most of my lost balls end up. It is long though so I lose one of the 14 spots in my bag, but I’m not good enough to need a full set anyway.
Rob C
1 year agoOh HELL NO!!!
shortside
1 year agoI Gotcha is worth it. Yes, muddy conditions is a bit dicey. You eventually get your money back and then some. Recall getting a good price on Amazon.