An Inside Look at The Golf Digest Hot List
News

An Inside Look at The Golf Digest Hot List

An Inside Look at The Golf Digest Hot List

Each and every year, Golf Digest’s annual Hot List issue is, without debate, the single most popular issue of any golf print publication. But exactly how clubs are selected and medals awarded is a bit of a mystery.

It’s time to peek behind the curtain.

Today we’re going to give you an inside look at a piece of the Hot List process that not many people get to see.

MyGolfSpy has obtained a copy of a document all Hot List nominees are asked to submit to Golf Digest. This form provides an opportunity for manufacturers to trumpet their technology and have their claims reviewed by Golf Digest’s technical panel.

Page one provides a brief explanation of the purpose of the form, which is described as the Form 1040EZ equivalent for any Hot List technical presentations. The form doesn’t dig too deeply into the specifics of exactly how the provided information will be evaluated, but it does provide a basic overview of the process, and offers 5 specific points that manufacturers should address in their explanation of technologies.

gdhl1

Page two provides manufacturers with an opportunity to describe, in detail, specific aspects of their technology, and to provide Golf Digest with any supporting documentation to validate said technology. Manufacturers are free to add as many copies of this page as they feel is necessary to fully outline their innovations.

This page is reviewed by Golf Digest panel of Technical Scientists (we understand these are not Golf Digest employees) in an attempt to determine the validity of the specified claims.
hot-list-questionnaire-redacted

While this isn’t an all-encompassing view of exactly how products are selected for the annual Hot List, it does provide some insight into a key piece of the process.

For You

For You

Golf Technology
Apr 25, 2024
Skillest is Reimagining Golf Instruction
Golf Bag Carts
Apr 25, 2024
Forum Member Review: Clicgear Model 4.0 Golf Push Cart
News
Apr 24, 2024
Are You Wearing the Right Size Shoe?
MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

Our mission is #ConsumerFirst. We are here to help educate and empower golfers. We want you to get the most out of your money, time and performance. That means providing you with equipment reviews you can trust, as well as honest reporting on the latest issues affecting the game today. #PowerToThePlayer

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

Driver Ping G30 Hybrids PXG 0317
3/4 IRON PXG 0311XF 5-GW Srixon Z 565
SW PXG 0317 LW PXG 0311
Putter EVNROLL  
MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy





    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

      13golfer

      8 years ago

      Again high end products missing: Miura, PXG etc. I have been blue eyed, these tests are bought by big money. Mizuno balls, why aren’t them on the list, they are good by the way

      Reply

      The Nak

      8 years ago

      Hot list is a joke. Do you honestly believe the magazine would risk losing advertising dollars by bad mouthing any manufacturers equipment. It’s nothing but a waste of paper.

      Reply

      THEHacker

      8 years ago

      Hot list is a waste of time, its always the same suspects that gets it, at best it is highly dependant on the wordings used in the submission. If you choose the right buzzwords, and impress the panel sufficiently, you’ll get mentioned.

      Reply

      redneckrooster

      8 years ago

      I believe this article is a waste of time. We all know the advertising decides the outcome and awards. My driver is 17yrds longer bla bla bla and we all would be hitting 500 + yards.
      I guess your running out of material !

      Reply

      MyGolfSpy

      8 years ago

      Not running out of material, far from that. This is something a subset of our readers have shown interest in so we published it. Waste of time for you we can appreciate that, for others it might not be. Have a great day RedNeck.

      Reply

      redneckrooster

      8 years ago

      TooShay:
      I do enjoy your articles, Your right someone is interested.

      Jim

      8 years ago

      The GD reviews are really just a fluff piece that you read every year. The don’t really tell you anything at all other than TM will have the best driver every year (at least it seems that way). Their reviews are so short and pointless that it’s almost comical. You really need to read this site and other similar ones to get a better idea of what each club presents. Again the GD reviews are just for fun in my opinion – they tell you very little.

      Reply

      James

      8 years ago

      Have been a golfer for 40 yrs, played since 14 yrs old. Was down to +2 handicap using off the shelve clubs, Trusted Mizuno irons with S300 shafts and Big Bertha Driver with S flex shaft, Then came along the custom fitting industry, Shafts that cost $200 for a driver, KBS, Steel Fibre, Modus 3, C Typre, Project X irons shafts, MOI, bla bla bla. In pursuit of a better game I went through 5 fitting sessions the past 6 yrs, every time different recommendations, new shafts, lighter shafts for faster swing, more distance consistency. The first fitting I did was with a PGA pro, who did not have any of the new technology except his eyes and experience. I was fitted with S300 shafts, Founders Club CB irons, most important get the feel right and driver was a Titleist with Grafalloy ProLight Regular shaft tipped slightly. I played with this setup for 7 yrs and down to +2 handicap. then the % fitting processes started. All indoors, TV screens, and I became a struggling 6/7 handicap player, first time in my life I played X100 or C-typre S flex shafts, Driver shaft Accra FX s+ shafts. 8 months ago after taking the clubs back and the fitter insisting that we do a comparative test, I told him to shove his clubs, Bought a set of Mizuno’s with S300 shafts, Titleist Driver with Aldilla Roque Black R flex shaft, 3 wood and 4 hybrid, Today 7 months later I am back to a 2 handicap. Remember, they have to retail to stay alive.

      Reply

      Chris Peyton

      8 years ago

      I want a job w MyGolf Spy !!!!! And a T-Shirt!!!!!!

      Reply

      NEF

      8 years ago

      I used to work in an industry that gave out a similar award list to the Hot List. Our awards very clearly reflected our advertising. One year we were left out of the awards and our owner made two phone calls. The next year he was named executive of the year in that industry and we won a slew of product and customer service awards. Yes, I do know this for certain. Not just a rumor, I was directly involved from our company’s side in getting the “oversight” corrected. The Hot List is no different. Anyone who thinks the rankings are truly independent leaves out cookies for Santa.

      Reply

      Tom54

      8 years ago

      It’s funny that they take applications at all considering the same companies win gold and the same companies win silver every single year. You can pick up a HotList mag from any year in the past 10 years and know who won without even turning the pages.

      Reply

      Largechris

      8 years ago

      Honestly these submission forms don’t seem particularly controversial. My small understanding of the hotlist however is that manufacturer awards coincidentally tend to align quite neatly with GD advertising spend each year. Eg Jollygolf 1.4 million per year equals 3 golds, 2 silvers. Piggygolf 1.2 million gets 2 golds 2 silvers. Hireko… Zero….

      Reply

      Guy Crawford

      8 years ago

      Very interesting

      Reply

      McaseyM

      8 years ago

      Is this just the screening tool to see what they will actually test? I wonder how many catalogs of info/tech specs they get for each item? Is there a place to attach the 3×5 manilla envelope?????

      Reply

      Scott Romines

      8 years ago

      This pretty much sums up the Golf Digest Hot List

      Reply

      Rob Nieth

      8 years ago

      You nailed it!

      Reply

      MyGolf Spy

      8 years ago

      This one had us laughing! This applies to so many things in our world today.

      Reply

    Leave A Reply

    required
    required
    required (your email address will not be published)

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Golf Technology
    Apr 25, 2024
    Skillest is Reimagining Golf Instruction
    Golf Bag Carts
    Apr 25, 2024
    Forum Member Review: Clicgear Model 4.0 Golf Push Cart
    News
    Apr 24, 2024
    Are You Wearing the Right Size Shoe?
    ENTER to WIN 3 DOZEN

    Titleist ProV1 Golf Balls

    Titleist ProV1 Golf Balls
    By signing up you agree to receive communications from MyGolfSpy and select partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy You may opt out of email messages/withdraw consent at any time.