Support our Mission. We independently test each product we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.
Attention all mid- to high-handicap golfers, golfers lacking swing speed or even those new to this beautiful game! Help is at hand! (Literally.)
Today, we review the best super game-improvement irons for 2023.
Super game-improvement irons are designed to help golfers achieve more consistent shot outcomes. They are specifically aimed at those who struggle to get the golf ball airborne.
They come in a variety of shapes and sizes. Some offer tremendous consistency and accuracy; others, enticing distance potential.
Finding the right super game-improvement irons can make the game so much more enjoyable. But who has the time to try all the different options? We do! So we did the hard work for you. Read on!
| Product | Overall Score |
|
|---|---|---|
| Mizuno JPX Hot Metal HL Check Price | 97.4 |
| Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Check Price | 91.1 |
| PING G430 HL Check Price | 90.8 |
| TaylorMade Stealth HD Check Price | 89.1 |
| Tour Edge Hot Launch E523 Check Price | 80.9 |
 | COBRA T-Rail Check Price | 79.0 |
 | Callaway Big Bertha 23’ Check Price | 71.6 |
Our overall rankings are a compilation of accuracy, distance and forgiveness. Each scoring category is weighted to achieve the overall score. We understand each iron category is different. For super game-improvement irons, score weightings are tighter, with forgiveness taking precedence over accuracy and distance.
Accuracy plays a vital role in overall performance. Our Accuracy score is strictly based on one metric:
Forgiveness is a measure of consistency. As such, our Forgiveness metrics seek to identify the clubs that provide the most consistent result. Please note: “Consistent” doesn’t always mean “consistently good.” Our Forgiveness metrics include:
Our Distance metrics are simple:
Performance should be your primary concern when buying new irons but there are some additional things you may want to think about before you make your decision.
Shaft selection is a key ingredient to any golf club purchase. In the super game-improvement iron category, graphite shaft options dominate. Why? Well, super game-improvement irons typically utilize lighter-weight components to maximize performance. After all, the target market is the golfer who struggles to hit iron shots with optimum launch conditions and descent angles.
Super game-improvement irons focus more on forgiveness and accuracy than distance. There are a few irons in this category that offer impressive distance potential. However, sometimes distance comes at the sake of accuracy and forgiveness. You must determine which performance attributes best fit your golf game and needs.
Most sets of super game-improvement irons won’t break your bank, even though most come stock with graphite shafts. Generally, you’ll see a $100 price difference between steel and graphite iron sets. The PING G430 HL has the highest retail price at $1,188.25 for a seven-piece set. Most of the other offerings are around $1,000 or less.
To determine this year’s best super game-improvement, 20 testers hit a total of 6,720 shots. Throughout the testing process, testers hit the 5-iron, 7-iron and pitching wedge from each participating model.
We limit variables by collecting data using Titleist ProV1 as our official testing golf ball and Foresight GCQuad as our official ball launch monitor.
Q: How often should I buy new irons?
A: While on rare occasions there are quantifiable year-over-year breakthroughs, typically it takes three to five years for manufacturers to make significant performance gains. With the USGA further tightening restrictions on manufacturers, it’s possible, even likely, that it will take longer still moving forward. Our recommendation is to buy new irons only when they appreciably outperform what is already in your bag. Of course, if you want new irons because you want new irons, that’s fine, too.
Q: How do I determine the right category of irons for me?
A: The four categories of irons we test are player’s (cavity-backs), player’s distance, game-improvement and super game-improvement. While there is some overlap between categories, your search should begin with an honest assessment of your skill level (handicap) as well as what you need in your game. While there are always exceptions, if your handicap is above 10 and ball striking is not a legitimate strength, we’d recommend avoiding the player’s iron category. For more skilled players who hit the ball more consistently, a set of player’s or player’s distance irons may benefit your game the most. For those on the bubble, especially for those seeking a few more yards, the player’s distance category is typically the most versatile.
Q: Does the shaft matter?
A: Absolutely. While changes to spin and launch differences are rarely massive, shaft changes frequently lead to improved accuracy, tighter dispersion and greater overall consistency. Finding the right shaft and dialing in your lie angles is reason enough to get fitted.
Q: What should I look for when testing irons?
A: While golfers have been conditioned to consider distance to the exclusion of nearly everything else, even within the super game-improvment iron category we recommend looking at the little numbers and looking for small circles. When comparing metrics like distance and ball speed, be sure to look at your standard deviations (the small numbers usually found under the big ones on the launch monitor data screen). Smaller numbers mean better consistency which will usually mean more than an extra yard or two on the golf course. Similarly, look for tighter dispersion ellipses (small circles). We can’t overstate the importance of consistency with irons.
Q: How are the irons in the test fitted to each golfer?
A: We use a fitting process that we call fit from stock. Irons are fitted to each tester using the stock, no up-charge options from each manufacturer. We test one short iron, one mid iron and one long iron from each set. While there are no irons in our testing that feature adjustability, we fit to flex for each tester in the pool. Occasionally, manufacturers will send multiple sets with different stock shafts that we can utilize to improve launch conditions.
Q: How do you determine in which category to test a given set of irons?
A: To ensure that we’re testing irons as alike as designers allow for, in addition to the design of the head itself (profile, sole width, etc.), we sort by length and loft. Our goal is to keep differences as minimal as possible within any test cohort. When an iron reasonably fits in more than one category, we defer to the manufacturer’s category choice.
Q: How are the Best Super Game-Improvement Irons determined?
A: To determine our rankings, we collect key performance metrics with Foresight GCQuad Launch Monitors. After eliminating outliers, we utilize a proprietary methodology to calculate overall scores for three key metrics: accuracy, forgiveness and distance. The Most Wanted winner is determined by the overall score after weighting these three metrics.
Q: How is the “Best for Distance” iron determined?
A: The process to determine the longest super game-improvement iron is similar to how we arrive at our overall rankings. For distance, our critical metrics are carry and total yards. We identify distance scores for each iron: 5, 7 and PW. From there, an overall score is calculated.
Q: How is the “Best for Forgiveness” iron determined?
A: Forgiveness scores are calculated based on four key metrics: spin delta, ball speed delta, carry delta and dispersion. A forgiveness score is generated, like distance, for each iron: 5, 7 and PW. From there, an overall score is calculated.
Q: You discuss subjective feedback for things like looks, sound and feel. How much do those ratings factor into your rankings?
A: ZERO. Our rankings are based purely on launch monitor data and quantifiable performance metrics.
Mizuno JPX 923 Hot Metal HL iron ranks as the best super game improvement iron 2023. It excels in two key performance areas - forgiveness and accuracy. JPX 923 Hot Metal HL is the best super game improvement for both of these scoring metrics. For distance, it ranks towards the bottom, which might be the cause of high lofted irons across the iron set. Our testing pool rates this iron highly for sound and looks as well.
Mizuno JPX 923 Hot Metal HL is the best super game improvement iron for a reason - it is forgiving and accurate. For most higher handicap golfers, forgiveness and accuracy should be paramount in the process of enhancing their golf game. Subjectively, JPX 923 Hot Metal HL ranks highly for sound and looks. It is arguably one of the more traditional looking irons in the super game improvement category.
Mizuno JPX 923 Hot Metal HL iron has one glaring weakness relative to the field and that is its distance performance. Traditional super game improvement irons tend to not be incredibly hot off the face, but more and more are taking steps towards prioritizing distance over accuracy and forgiveness. If distance is your goal, Mizuno JPX 923 Hot Metal HL might not be your first choice.
| OVERVIEW | PERFORMANCE | RANKING | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Accuracy evaluates if a player’s shots with each club are above or below what’s expected based on that player’s skill level. |
|
1st |
|
Our distance scoring is a metric ultimately telling you the total yards achieved by the club |
|
6th |
|
Forgiveness measures how well a club corrects for hits that are center or off center off the face of the club. |
|
1st |
|
Ball speed measures how fast the ball is traveling off the face of the club. |
|
6th |
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS iron ranks 2nd overall for the best super game improvement irons 2023. Last year, Rogue ST Max OS placed 1st overall in this test and once again, it proves just how solid of a golf iron it is. This iron did not rank 1st in any of the three scoring categories. However, it ranks 3rd for distance, which is strong for this category. Additionally, it ranks 3rd for accuracy. A golf iron that is accurate and provides decent distance potential is a solid combination for most golfers. It also ranks highly for sound and looks according to our testing pool.
Distance and accuracy are Callaway Rogue ST Max OS iron's strengths. It places in the top 3 for each scoring metric, which makes for a stellar combination for golfers looking for both attributes. Mid to higher handicap golfers or even beginner golfers should certainly consider Callaway Rogue ST Max OS iron as their next potential iron purchase.
Forgiveness is Callaway Rogue ST Max OS iron's poorest scoring metric. Its overall score for this category is slightly below average relative to the field. For us, forgiveness is a measurement of four key metrics - ball speed deltas, carry distance deltas, backspin deltas, and dispersion.
| OVERVIEW | PERFORMANCE | RANKING | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Accuracy evaluates if a player’s shots with each club are above or below what’s expected based on that player’s skill level. |
|
3rd |
|
Our distance scoring is a metric ultimately telling you the total yards achieved by the club |
|
3rd |
|
Forgiveness measures how well a club corrects for hits that are center or off center off the face of the club. |
|
4th |
|
Ball speed measures how fast the ball is traveling off the face of the club. |
|
1st |
Answer a few questions about your swing, and we’ll match your game to our database of over 100,000 swings. With 97.8% of swings matched, we’ll recommend the top performing drivers that will give you the best results. Maximize your potential with advanced golf analytics powered by MyGolfSpy.
PING G430 HL iron definitely turned heads in this category. It ranks 3rd overall and swept the floor with our subjective feedback awards as the best for sound, feel, looks and likelihood of purchase. It ranks 2nd overall for distance, which was evident from the onset of testing the super game improvement iron category. It also places 4th for accuracy, which adds pedigree to its overall performance.
Our testing pool rates PING G430 HL iron as the best super game improvement iron across all subjective categories - sound, feel, looks and likelihood of purchase. G430 HL iron is similar to the G430 iron, however, it offers weaker lofts and lightweight components. It boasts a tremendous distance ranking as 2nd overall and also performs reasonably for accuracy.
PING G430 HL iron ranks towards the bottom for forgiveness. Compared to the field it is below average. Again, we look at forgiveness as a measurement of four key metrics - ball speed deltas, carry distance deltas, backspin deltas, and dispersion.
| OVERVIEW | PERFORMANCE | RANKING | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Accuracy evaluates if a player’s shots with each club are above or below what’s expected based on that player’s skill level. |
|
4th |
|
Our distance scoring is a metric ultimately telling you the total yards achieved by the club |
|
2nd |
|
Forgiveness measures how well a club corrects for hits that are center or off center off the face of the club. |
|
5th |
|
Ball speed measures how fast the ball is traveling off the face of the club. |
|
3rd |
TaylorMade Stealth HD iron places 4th overall in the best super game improvement irons 2023 test. TaylorMade has had tremendous success with their Stealth family of irons and continues to do so with the Stealth HD. Stealth HD iron is the 2nd best super game improvement iron for forgiveness, which looks at ball speed deltas, carry distance deltas, backspin deltas, and dispersion.
Super game improvement irons put an emphasis on forgiveness since their target market is higher handicap golfers and beginner golfers. TaylorMade Stealth HD irons are one of the best super game improvement irons for forgiveness as it ranks 2nd for this scoring metric. It also offers appealing acoustics according to our testers.
Throughout testing, it was visble that Stealth HD iron was one of the shortest super game improvement irons. It ranks towards the bottom for this category, which may turn away some golfers.
| OVERVIEW | PERFORMANCE | RANKING | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Accuracy evaluates if a player’s shots with each club are above or below what’s expected based on that player’s skill level. |
|
5th |
|
Our distance scoring is a metric ultimately telling you the total yards achieved by the club |
|
5th |
|
Forgiveness measures how well a club corrects for hits that are center or off center off the face of the club. |
|
2nd |
|
Ball speed measures how fast the ball is traveling off the face of the club. |
|
5th |
Tour Edge Hot Launch E523 is as traditional as it gets for the super game improvement iron category. This "hybrid-like" iron or ironwood as Tour Edge labels it, places 5th overall, which is towards the bottom for this test. Tour Edge Hot Launch E523 is one of the best super game improvement irons for accuracy and ranks 2nd for this scoring category. It does not rank well for subjective feedback across the board i.e. sound, looks, and feel.
If you are a high handicap golfer or beginner golfer, Tour Edge Hot Launch E523 will be a great iron to purchase if you value accuracy. It ranks 2nd overall for accuracy in our best super game improvement iron 2023 test. Additionally, it ranks 3rd overall for forgiveness, which emphasizes consistent performance across the club face.
Distance is Tour Edge Hot Launch E523's weakness. Traditionally, it is not its forte in this category and this continues to show. If you are a higher handicap golfer and you prioritize distance, Tour Edge Hot Launch E523 iron might not be your first choice. There are hotter, longer super game improvement irons on the market.
| OVERVIEW | PERFORMANCE | RANKING | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Accuracy evaluates if a player’s shots with each club are above or below what’s expected based on that player’s skill level. |
|
2nd |
|
Our distance scoring is a metric ultimately telling you the total yards achieved by the club |
|
7th |
|
Forgiveness measures how well a club corrects for hits that are center or off center off the face of the club. |
|
3rd |
|
Ball speed measures how fast the ball is traveling off the face of the club. |
|
7th |
Choose a club category and pick two options to compare head-to-head. We'll show the stats from our testing side-by-side to see which ranks highest on the aspects that matter to you most. May the best club win!
See Head-to-HeadAccuracy plays a vital role in overall performance. Our Accuracy score is strictly based on one metric:
Our Distance metrics are simple:
Forgiveness is a measure of consistency. As such, our Forgiveness metrics seek to identify the clubs that provide the most consistent result. Please note: “Consistent” doesn’t always mean “consistently good.” Our Forgiveness metrics include:
Everything we do and say is based on cold, hard data. We challenge any and every claim with scientific measurement and analysis. If a product performs well, you'll hear about it. We'll tell you the truth and list the shortcomings if it doesn't.
learn more
Balls hit
+hours on
range
tests
completed
companies
trialed
Everything we do and say is based on cold, hard data. We challenge any and every claim with scientific measurement and analysis. If a product performs well, you'll hear about it. We'll tell you the truth and list the shortcomings if it doesn't.
Looking for more detailed information on the super game-improvement irons?
Looking for more detailed information on the super game-improvement irons?
DID YOU KNOW: If only 1% of MyGolfSpy readers donated $25, we would be able to become completely independent in 12-months. With every donation, you create change.
Would you be willing to help by giving a donation? Every dollar will help. Make a donation to support our independent and expert golf equipment research. A PayPal account is not required in order to donate.
Our mission is #ConsumerFirst. We are here to help educate and empower golfers. We want you to get the most out of your money, time and performance. That means providing you with equipment reviews you can trust, as well as honest reporting on the latest issues affecting the game today. #PowerToThePlayer
| Driver Ping G30 | Hybrids PXG 0317 |
| 3/4 IRON PXG 0311XF | 5-GW Srixon Z 565 |
| SW PXG 0317 | LW PXG 0311 |
| Putter EVNROLL |
10 months ago
I miss the old charts where you can see all the choices head to head. Head to head is great as a final thing to look at.
10 months ago
Come on MyGolfSpy staff. You’re smart people, surely you can come up with a way to measure distance based upon the degrees of loft.
Only then can you make some sort of distance assessment since there is no standard for a 7-iron’s loft.
You hear this comment in almost every new iron review, you can do better than this and your legions of fans and supporters expect it.
10 months ago
Static loft is far too narrow a measurement to use as a definitive predictor of distance. You have to account for all the components of the design, not the least of which are mass properties/CG location. Then there’s sole width, face thickness, internal structures, etc.
I get that plenty of golfers think that less loft = more distance and that’s the end of the story. But it isn’t.
Side note – Last week Tony and I hit four different models of irons….and for both of us, the one with strongest loft had the highest peak height.
Dynamics matter. Static measurements are easy fodder for debate, but the best way to test for distance is to put the clubs in the hands of real golfers and see what happens.
10 months ago
Thanks but the Big Bertha 7i at 27* vs the JPX 923 HL at 31*, for example, is not really apples to apples.
10 months ago
Ping G430 standard is 29 and Power Spec is 27.5.
Even doing just that comparison on here would be enough to show you what would happen.
10 months ago
Where is the Cleveland XL Halo???
10 months ago
Sorry but after owning MIZUNO JPX 921 and the Tour Edge 523 I was fortunate enough to try XXIO’s and found the air I needed. I was so impressed that I then added the Driver, 5FW and 4 Hybrid. Wow. I’m a 15 year HS golf coach ( Girls State Champions 2023) and after a car wreck that put pins in my back and the GBS at 69 I lost my swing speed. I tried the TE 523’s for 6 months but couldn’t master them. Turned out same hole I was using a 6 iron Tour Edge was a pitching wedge with the XXIO’s. Amazing height . Expensive but worth every penny. Hope this helps. Ps bought them through Curated.com because they had a 14 day return policy. Ask for Chris you might get a discount if you give them my name.
10 months ago
There’s a reason why XXIO is the Number 1 brand in Japan
10 months ago
Where’s the XXIO???
10 months ago
Throw out the distance metric if you are buying new irons. It’s near meaningless because there are different lofts on many of these clubs. A 5 iron in one will be a 5-1/2 or 6 iron in others. The only time distance matters is at the “top” of the set. Those “spots” can be filled with a hybrid or 2 or a high lofted fairway wood. You can re-rank these sets by only using the forgiveness and accuracy metrics.
10 months ago
Lots of good data to really informative. Question, when you say the stealth HD irons are low in the distance criteria, could it be that there lofts are 1 to 1.5° weaker than the other clubs tested?
10 months ago
Another great article with tons of useful information.
I would like to see every SGII and GII all start with one of the most ignored phrase in golf, “get fitted and don’t just buy off the rack.” After that phrase, a link to a MSG article why golfers in this category should be fitted. Obviously, the better players already understand the value of a fitting. I know this is buried in the question, how are the testers fitted. I’m guessing many beginners are not aware that they have several choices when it comes to shafts.
Just my $.02 or less, considering inflation.
10 months ago
Getting fit for any golf club is paramount. Even for beginners, being fit for proper length and lie can be effective at a minimum. The beauty of super game improvement irons though is that their designs can benefit golfers effectively enough off the rack or as is.
10 months ago
Where’s the Cleveland????
10 months ago
Yes!
10 months ago
Cleveland Launcher XL Halo irons were tested in last year’s Super Game-Improvement Irons buyer’s guide. Check it out here – https://mygolfspy.com/buyers-guides/irons/2022-most-wanted-super-game-improvement-iron/
Titleist ProV1 Golf Balls
Jon Dillingham
3 months ago
Love the testing great info. Really considering the JPX 923 HL. Problem with test comparing a 27 degree club to a 31 degree club is apple’s and oranges. Easy to see why the 31 degree JPX 923HL is shorter it is lower loft competitors duh! But is it more forgiving and more accurate because it’s got higher loft? Who knows?
This could have easily been rectified by comparing the 28 degree JPX 923HL 6 iron against everyone else’s 7 irons of nearly equal loft. Then the forgiveness/accuracy numbers resulting would have more validity.