In our Tuesday newsletter (which you should definitely sign up for), I asked you to send me the golf rules you would most like to change, written or unwritten.
I figured I would hear about fairway divots, which I have famously argued should not entitle golfers to free relief (the MGS staff is still mad at me for this one). I did not, however, figure I would be embattled in several debates at once where I’m sending photographic evidence of various fairway lies that may or may not be in divots.
That’s where this went. We also got into white stakes, why we still call them the “women’s tees” and whether you need a graduate degree to get through the Rules of Golf.
Here’s what you sent me and where I landed. Thank you to everyone who participated.
Should you get free relief from a fairway divot?
“Hey you’ve hit the ball to its intended resting spot and shouldn’t be penalized for good execution.” — Gale Nicely
Duane Martin from Deadhorse, Alaska, was one of many readers who wrote in to make the case that divots should be treated as ground under repair. He later narrowed that to bare divots where a swing took out the sod and nobody had filled the hole with sand. Gale would trust players to recognize an obvious divot. Ron made a competition-specific point, saying some holes funnel tee shots into the same patch of fairway so players arriving later in the day may have more divots to contend with, which is unfair. He pointed to the green where we now let players repair spike and ball marks. He would make a rule that balls finishing in fresh, unrepaired or sand-filled fairway divots are worthy of free relief. Playing partners or rules officials would determine whether the lie reaches such a level.
My take
It’s a lousy break. In a casual round with friends, move it out of the divot and get on with your day. In a tournament, I still want someone to show me the wording we can use to make a rule that makes sense for all golfers—whether it’s on a pristine fairway or a scruffy muni. How fresh is fresh? When does a partly healed divot become an ordinary depression?
That’s how Ron ended up with five photos of various fairway lies in his inbox. His answer was that he would give relief from the ones that would affect the shot which he couldn’t always tell from a photo. Fair enough. But if we went out to a local muni, I could show you a dozen different fairway lies within a 20-foot circle. They all affect the shot slightly differently. So where do we draw the line? It’s impossible.
I still think a rule needs to help two groups looking at the same lie reach the same decision. Repairing a spike mark also leaves the ball where it is. Divot relief means deciding when a player gets to move it. I’m open to a definition that works but I haven’t heard one that gets me there yet.
I never will hear one. Playing the ball as it lies is integral to the game. This isn’t sim golf and you aren’t guaranteed a perfect lie every time you hit the fairway, just as you aren’t guaranteed a poor lie every time you miss the fairway.
It’s not feasible and it’s completely antithetical to the game to establish “fairness” based on how some arbitrary code.
Ask a dozen rules officials and report back to me.
Is stroke and distance too harsh?
“I’m not a fan of stroke and distance, not at all, make everything red stakes, including the property boundary.” — Nat Piper
Michael Brown zeroed in on the walk back to the tee when someone hasn’t hit a provisional. Gale wondered why misses on opposite sides of the same fairway could get such different treatment. Dan Salmon pushed back, saying different boundaries can have different consequences and being able to spot your ball on the other side of a white stake doesn’t make it any less out of bounds.
My take
White stakes are my least favorite rule in golf. Dan has a point about the psychological effect of being able to see your ball but my gripe is the severity of the penalty and the trip back to the tee, especially on courses with houses lining both sides of a hole (golf rules weren’t written with that common architecture flaw in mind).
Where Model Local Rule E-5 is in effect, you can take a drop in a relief area that extends to the fairway and add two penalty strokes. After an OB drive, you’re hitting four. I’d rather see a one-stroke option near where the ball went out and have you hitting three. And while I’ll admit internal out of bounds can make for good television at The Open, most of the time it feels gimmicky.
Why can’t I hit a provisional for a ball that might be in a penalty area?
“My suggestion – make Model Local Rule B-3 (Provisional Ball for Ball in a Penalty Area) part of the Rules. It’s a great time saver.” — Paula Fairley
My take
I’m with Paula. Think of a blind shot where the ball could be in the penalty area or sitting just outside it. You walk up, figure out what happened and may have to walk back to play again. Under B-3, a committee can designate a penalty area where you can announce and play a provisional using the applicable relief options.
That’s a practical way to keep a group moving. We already have a version of the rule for places where the walk up and back creates a problem. I’d put that option in the Rules of Golf.
Do we really need red and yellow penalty areas?
“Get rid of multiple designations for water hazards, Red vs Yellow, and make all water hazards the same penalty and option for the next shot.” — Mike
Mike would let you play it as it lies or take a one-stroke penalty and drop back from where it entered. I understand the appeal of having one set of options.
My take
Think about the closing holes at TPC Sawgrass.
On an island green like No. 17, allowing lateral relief (red stakes) could open up a drop right by the green for a shot that flew it. You would be putting for par from the back of the green. That’s not how the hole was designed.
On a hole like No. 18, where water runs along the side, lateral relief lets you drop near where the ball crossed instead of trying to find a workable spot on a line that runs back across the lake (some hundreds of yards away, in this instance).
Red and yellow markings let a course account for how the water actually comes into play. I’d keep both.
Should the flagstick come out again?
“Go back to taking the flagstick out when on the green…” — Brent Silber
Dan also took issue with the idea that letting players leave the pin in speeds things up. Brent followed up with a point in its favor. For some putters, it gives them something to aim at.
My take
I take it out unless I’m a million miles away and playing alone. Putting with it in still feels wrong to me. I’m also with Dan in doubting that it makes much of any difference to pace. But if you like having something to aim at, go ahead and leave it in. I see no reason to bring back a penalty for that.
Can we let PGA Tour players wear shorts?
“I don’t understand why people get so upset over unimportant topics like clothing in golf, and yet we’re still struggling with four-and-a-half to five hour rounds!” — Kyle Ericson
My take
We recently tackled this topic as Arjun Chowdri wrote a column in defense of shorts.
My take is let them wear shorts in regular Tour events, especially when it’s hot. There is no functional reason to make them wear pants in those situations. I’d still like to see pants at events like the Masters and The Open which aren’t in warmer climates anyway. I’ll own being a little old-fashioned there. At my own course, I’m comfortable in a pretty standard golf outfit and I’m happy to play alongside somebody who feels differently.
Can we rethink the way a round is supposed to look?
Nat had a lot more than white stakes on his list. He’d play 12 holes if given the choice. He wants more ready golf, tees chosen by yardage instead of gender, more walking and fewer putts picked up. He would also like you to play it down, divots and all, and buy the first round.
My take
As a dad, I would love to see more 12-hole rates. Nine can leave me wanting a few more and by the time I drive to the course, warm up, play 18 and drive home, I’ve used up a good chunk of the day.
I would happily retire the men’s and women’s tee labels. Pick the yardage that gives you the round you want and mix tees if the course gives you that option. Walk when you can. If you’re ready to hit and the other player is still getting organized, go ahead when it’s safe. And after all the “divots should be ground under repair” emails, Nat, I appreciated hearing from somebody who wants to play the ball as it lies (as the golf gods intended).
Why does the rulebook read like a graduate course?
“Why is it that the rules of golf are explained in a manner where you need a masters degree to understand them?” — John Herman
My take
If it were up to me, the rulebook would be about 10 pages long (in reality, it’s 244 pages). Then I look at an email chain where two golfers are trying to decide which of five fairway lies should get relief and remember how we got here. The governing bodies have made an effort to simplify things which I appreciate. I would still like to see how much further they can go.
Thanks to everybody who wrote in. If you’ve got a definition of a fairway divot that would work at your muni and in the final group of a major, I’m still listening—but be prepared for a passionate debate.
Eric
5 seconds ago
These sort of discussions are always funny to me, if you don’t like the rules don’t play in tournaments. Otherwise you are not obligated to follow any of the rules if you don’t want to. Also, Nat absolutely has the choice to only play 12 holes, no one is going to stop them driving back to the clubhouse after the 12th green.