Scratch By 50: I Put the Clubs I Hate Back in My Bag
News

Scratch By 50: I Put the Clubs I Hate Back in My Bag

Support our Mission. We independently test each product we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

Scratch By 50: I Put the Clubs I Hate Back in My Bag

Graham Averill has turned 50 this year and he’s freaking out. Instead of buying a motorcycle or getting a tattoo, he’s decided to try to get really, really good at golf. He started this project as a 13 handicap attempting to reach scratch in a year. He is now a 6.6.. Welcome to his midlife crisis.

I don’t play with a full set of clubs. Not long after picking up golf again a few years ago, I pulled the 3-wood, 5-wood and hybrid out of my bag and vowed never to use them again. About six months ago, I swore off the 60-degree wedge. There’s too much scar tissue around those particular sticks. Too many fat shots with the 60, too many big misses with the fairway woods. 

A lot of golfers eliminate clubs they don’t trust from their bags. The thought process is simple: if you slice your 5-wood into the woods every time, stop trying to hit the 5-wood. Just lay up with a 5-iron instead. Play it safe and avoid a blow-up hole. 

It makes sense but not if you’re trying to get better at golf. 

I was listening to the podcast “The Sweet Spot” with Jon Sherman, author of “The Four Foundations of Golf”. He and his co-host were talking about golfers who have taken the driver out of their bag. They were debating whether hitting the safe club off the tee was the best solution. If you don’t know where your driver is going to land and you can hit a 3-iron 210 yards to the middle of the fairway, should you just hit the 3-iron? 

A lot of golfers would say play the safe shot. Sherman agreed but only if your goal was to shoot the lowest score possible on that day. If you have the long-term goal of getting better at golf, leaving the driver in the bag isn’t going to do you any good. If you truly want to get better, Sherman insists you have to get comfortable using the clubs that make you uncomfortable.

I know he’s right. There are gaps in my yardages because I don’t use fairway woods and there are gaps in my short game because I loathe the 60-degree so I’ve put these clubs back into my bag. 

My issue with the 60-degree is just mental. Too many chunked shots and bladed shots have built up too much scar tissue but I know if I practice with it more and use it more on the course, I’ll get comfortable with it. And I play a lot of courses with elevated greens that are protected by water and bunkers so the 60-degree can be a handy tool. 

The fairway woods are a different issue. Sure, there’s also scar tissue around these clubs but there are also some technical issues. I had the ball position and swing mechanics wrong. I was playing the ball way too far back in my stance and trying to hit down on it like an iron. It contributed to some low-point control issues. So I’ve moved the ball up to the inside of my lead heel and started trying to brush the grass with the club head. 

I make a point to practice both the 5-wood and mini driver on the range, focusing on half swings where I’m trying to feel the sole of the club glide across the ground at impact. I try to keep that feel through full swings and take it onto the course. It isn’t perfect but I’ve had some success and played a particularly tough par-5 beautifully with two well-placed 5-wood shots. It’s the best I’ve ever played that hole.

Then I shanked a tee shot with the same 5-wood on the very next hole because, you know, golf. 

There’s a timeline to my current scratch goal so it can be difficult to convince myself to use these clubs during scoring rounds on the course but I know that sometimes you have to sacrifice short-term success for long-term goals. And putting these clubs back into my bag actually paid off during my last round. 

I spent a lot of time traveling and working on a better turn over the last week so I only had the time to play a single nine-hole round at my home course. But I made the most of it. I played from the back tees, which bumped up the course rating, and shot two under par on the front nine. I tried not to think too much about the biomechanics of my turn and I just played but I did make a point to use the fairway woods and 60-degree lob wedge if the opportunity presented itself. I never had to pull the 5-wood out of the bag but there were three shots that called for the lob wedge. I was honestly nervous each time I pulled that club because I had a good score going but it worked out beautifully. I tracked every shot with Arccos and placed each lob wedge shot within 12 feet of the hole over bunkers from a few different distances ranging from 15 to 40 yards out. 

The round brought my handicap down to 6.6. And Arccos declared the 60-degree to be the MVP of the round so that’s a nice little reward for stepping out of my comfort zone. 

Dig deeper into one golfer’s struggle to get better at golf in middle age and read last week’s Scratch By 50 where Graham finally learns how to make a proper turn. 

For You

For You

JumboMax JMX Ultralong golf grip JumboMax JMX Ultralong golf grip
Golf Grips
Nov 19, 2026
I’ve Tried Some Crazy S*^t In My Golf Career But This Might Be The Craziest
News
Nov 19, 2026
What’s The Difference Between A $4K, $7K and $29K Golf Simulator?
News
Nov 19, 2026
This Is What Kids Clubs Should Be
Preferred Source
Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill

Graham Averill





      DaVe

      13 minutes ago

      I have 3 problem children in my bag: the 3w, the 4h and the 9i. The 3w was so bad that I never used it. Recently, I made it a point to figure out that club. As a side benefit, figuring out the 3w improved my driver results too. My good shot percentage with it is still below my other clubs, but I don’t fear it anymore. The 4h was/is a hosel monster. I think it’s the shaft. I have to try to hit the toe in order to hit the middle of the face. It still freaks me out, but it works. The 9i is also a hosel monster, and I can’t blame the shaft. I have no problem with my identically built PW and 8i. But the 9i refuses to cooperate. I have a couple sets of irons and it’s always the 9i. It’s mental. Anyway, these days I spend most of my range time working on those 3 clubs.

      Reply

      Graham Averill

      5 seconds ago

      That’s interesting that you have issues with the 9 iron and fairway woods. usually, it’s one or the other. But trying to hit the ball off a specific part of the club face is a legit teaching tool, and something I’m going to write about soon, so thanks for bringing that up. and I totally agree about the mental aspect. that’s the 60 for me. all mental. I’m getting over it.

      Reply

      Kevin C

      28 minutes ago

      People still carry a 3 iron? I’m almost ready to give up the 5 iron. I can see taking the 60 out of a bag if you’re not going to commit to it.
      Assuming you’re not carrying a 3i, I would guess a fitter would need to figure out a hybrid or fairway wood for you. At my age and distance I need them for some par 3’s since my 5i is maxed at 180. I would let a good fitter do that rather than trying to just slot one into your bag that you don’t get along with. It took me awhile but I would give up an iron before I took the hybrid out of my bag. I’m hoping to get fit to a fairway wood or another hybrid that suits me as well.

      Reply

      Graham Averill

      2 minutes ago

      nah, I don’t carry a three iron. I’m curious about driving irons though. I’m not sure that I would use one personally, but the concept is fascinating to me. I think the setup issues were the main issue with my five wood. I don’t have a hybrid, but I could see getting fit for one soon. I know a lot of golfers love them and I’m curious about the hype.

      Reply

      Fake

      3 hours ago

      My chipping is is terrible, and the irony is that I don’t practice it because…I’m terrible, and it’s not fun. And then I skull most of my chips, or they go way short. I don’t trust the clubs, the balls, or myself.

      I didn’t play much this past year due to some family health issues, but it’s my goal to put in more chipping practice than anything else this upcoming season. And I’m guessing that I’ll get lower scores and I’ll actually grow to enjoy that part of the game.

      Best of luck, Graham. You’re showing us some cool stuff here.

      Reply

      Graham Averill

      5 minutes ago

      Thanks Fake. I used to hate chipping too, but then dedicated a significant portion of my practice sessions to it. Now it’s my favorite part of practice, and probably the best part of my game. I bet if you dig into it, you’ll end up loving it too. I appreciate you reading and commenting.

      Reply

      Mike

      3 hours ago

      Must be nice to “leave the driver in the bag & just hit my 3 iron 210 yds”. LOL What small % of golfer can realistically (& consistently) do that?

      So let’s look at this from an average golfer perspective. I struggled w/ driver for years. Went to a mini-driver but found I gave up too many yards because “clubbing down” wasn’t as accurate as I thought it w/b. But today there are so many options w/ drivers & shafts & I had a good fitter at 2nd Swing who found the right combo for me. Now I love hitting driver! But I have learned as I’ve gotten older, since I’m not playing from the long tees anymore, not to get greedy w/ my driver swing. Make a smooth one & get it in the fairway.

      Reply

      Graham Averill

      6 minutes ago

      I totally agree that getting properly fit for the clubs can often solve the problem. I just went through an extensive fitting process that I’m excited to write about.

      Reply

    Leave A Reply

    required
    required
    required (your email address will not be published)

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    JumboMax JMX Ultralong golf grip JumboMax JMX Ultralong golf grip
    Golf Grips
    Nov 19, 2026
    I’ve Tried Some Crazy S*^t In My Golf Career But This Might Be The Craziest
    News
    Nov 19, 2026
    What’s The Difference Between A $4K, $7K and $29K Golf Simulator?
    News
    Nov 19, 2026
    This Is What Kids Clubs Should Be