Key Takeways
- What makes the BirdieBall putting mat roll like a real green? Aerated polymers.
- BirdieBall putting mat is the only mat out there with grain to simulate putting with or against the grain on a real green.
- More than half a million BirdieBall putting mats have been sold, with a less than a one-percent return rate.
- 300-percent sales growth over the past year has BirdieBall looking for a new facility.
The secret that makes BirdieBall the king of putting mats is something you’ve probably never heard of: aerated polymers.
Yeah, I know. From the looks of it, you’d think it’s plain old foam, right? But according to John Breaker—BirdieBall’s owner, inventor and wannabe Elon Musk—you’d be wrong.
“We have this bias in our culture about foam being cheap and readily available,” says Breaker. “Our BirdieBall mat is quite the contrary. We go to great lengths to create a foam that functions like a real green. And there’s nothing cheap about it.”
In fact, “foam” is disdained as just another four-letter word at BirdieBall. The appropriate term is “aerated polymer.”
As you’ll discover, aerated polymers are at the root (pardon the pun) of BirdieBall’s putting mats.
BirdieBall and the Spongy Subbase
The BirdieBall putting mat galloped away from the field like Secretariat in last year’s MyGolfSpy Indoor Putting Mat Buyer’s Guide. And the more you investigate, the more you learn that the secret is in the subbase.
The BirdieBall putting mat is fundamentally different. Everything else is like a carpet or a mat. BirdieBall is foam. Breaker says that’s no accident.
“Look at the natural grass cross-section of a healthy, vibrant putting green,” he says. “It has a grass top layer and, right below it, is a very robust root layer. That’s where all the nutrients come in. It’s little fibrils of roots and it’s a very spongy subbase.”
The healthier the green, the thicker the subbase and, by definition, the spongier it is. As golfers, we hate late summer/early fall because that’s when greens get aerated but aeration makes greens more plush.
“Most modern greens are mowed so short—down to .001 of an inch—that the ball doesn’t travel on blades of grass,” says Breaker. “It actually rides on the spongy subbase. That’s why you see them roll greens. People walk on them; mowers ride on them. They need to be flat.”
So when it comes to a putting mat, how do you replicate that spongy subbase?
That’s where aerated polymers come in.
Fibrils and Foam
“Take any other putting mat in the world, other than ours, there’s a texture and a pattern,” insists Breaker. “The ball will ride on that texture and pattern. That’s why we decided to focus on the subbase and then create a grass-like fibril.”
Breaker has one of the more unique backgrounds in the golf business. He worked many years ago for one of the inventors of Teflon and holds several patents in the oil and gas industry. And he knows polymers.
That knowledge of polymers along with a profound frustration with is own putting skills led Beaker to aerated polymers and the BirdieBall putting mat.
“Aerating a green grows the root system,” says Breaker. “Aerating our polymer creates this spongy subbase. The two look different but they provide the same functionality, which is to compress under load. You don’t want too spongy but you do want spongy enough.”
If you’re expecting a traditional textile-type putting mat, pulling a big chunk of foam out of the box can be a bit jarring. Breaker says that’s becoming less of an issue since buyers are doing more research on the product and know what to expect.
“We’ve been doing this for over 10 years now and we’ve sold over half a million putting greens,” he says. “It’s a 100-percent different experience than a woven textile putting mat, that’s for sure. But when it comes to true roll, those textile greens have a pattern and the ball might go down one pattern one time and another pattern another time.
“Textile has a pattern and you want to eliminate any pattern because the ball wants to track into a pattern. God makes real greens very random and randomness is important.”
BirdieBall: It’s Not Easy Being Green
Take a close look at a cross-section of a BirdieBall putting mat and it looks kind of like hairy lime Jell-O. The subbase—the aerated polymer part—is cellular and the top is brushed to create tiny fibrils meant to emulate the grain.
“It’s angled slightly in one direction so the ball will roll either into or with the grain,” says Breaker. “Into the grain, there’s more resistance. With the grain, there’s less because the fibril is down, allowing the ball to roll faster.”
BirdieBall sells a green-refreshing brush. Among other things, it allows you to change the speed of the green by brushing the fibrils up or down.
“We’re the first company to even talk about Stimp readings on indoor putting mats,” says Breaker’s daughter, Katie, who runs BirdieBall’s marketing department. “That’s because we’re the only mat with a grain feature. We’re not just mimicking the roll exactly; we’re actually replicating speed.”
Still, the fact the BirdieBall putting mat isn’t a deep, dark green like every other putting mat can concern a first-timer.
“People have been so conditioned,” adds Katie. “We’re the only company replicating an accurate roll but people don’t see carpet or a turf-like product when they open our box so they’re initially shocked and don’t understand how this could act anything like a natural putting surface.”
Despite that, BirdieBall has a less than one-percent return rate largely due to the fact its customers tend to be more serious golfers.
“A lot of the ‘it’s just foam’ complaints come from people who just want something that looks the part of a putting green, not something that could help take strokes off their game,” says Katie. “That’s a different customer. They just want something that looks cool.”
Rocky Mountain High or Get Out of Denver?
2020 was a very good year for BirdieBall. Sales exploded by 200 percent for the Evergreen, Colo., company. But often success brings unintended consequences.
“We’re growing so fast we may have to move out of the mountains,” says Breaker. “We have a super-nice facility in a beautiful part of the country but we’re literally working on top of one another. We may have to move somewhere flatter where we can get more space.”
The COVID pandemic surely turbocharged BirdieBall’s growth. And while tripling the business obviously isn’t sustainable, Breaker says sales are still riding in the fast lane.
“We did all our December sales on Black Friday,” says Breaker. “Starting Dec. 1, we didn’t promise anything for Christmas. It was all pre-order that we said we’d ship by Jan. 30. Nothing slowed down. Orders kept coming in and they’re still coming in. We had to take 10 days off. We just couldn’t keep our foot on that gas that hard. Everyone got nice bonuses but you’re just tired. It’s exhausting.”
Breaker does believe COVID-fueled change in buying behavior will leave a lasting mark.
“When DICK’S and other retailers shut down, the demand didn’t go up so much as accessibility went down,” he says. “Retail stores are back but I think buying behavior has changed. People see they can get something in two days from Amazon or in three days directly from us.”
Breaker keeps coming up with enhancements to the BirdieBall putting mat. You can order an incline kit to simulate uphill putts and there’s a Double Depth kit to provide a full inch of drop into the hole. As for size, you can order a BirdieBall putting mat as large as four feet by 30 feet if you have the space.
Call StarKist
John Breaker is an idea man, just like Bill Blazejowski, aka Billy Blaze from the 1982 Henry Winkler-Michael Keaton comedy Night Shift.
“Even my patent attorney quotes that movie to me,” laughs Breaker.
And while he hasn’t figured out how to feed mayonnaise to tuna fish, ideas do come charging at him all day long.
“I’ll walk into my kids’ office twice a day and say, ‘how about this one?’” says Breaker. “They’ll literally laugh out loud and go ‘no, no, no.’ You have to have a tough audience but that doesn’t stop the invention machine.”
And while he may sound like the mad-scientist type, in truth, Breaker is equal parts inventor and entrepreneur.
“People send me patented golf ideas all the time,” he says. “But there’s a difference between patents and patents that are functional. Something may be unique but is it solving a problem? Is there going to be a demand for it? If there isn’t, then there’s no sense in patenting it. Don’t even bother.”
To put it another way, the entrepreneur/inventor sees a problem and tries to find a practical, workable solution. The mad scientist, on the other hand, comes up with a solution and then tries to find a problem for it to solve.
“I was trying to improve my putting and everything on the market was either a woven synthetic piece of grass where the ball would just roll on top and not track at all,” he says. “Or it was something that went uphill at the end, which didn’t tell me anything about speed. I wanted to find a combination of rolling it right and then having it fall into the hole without going uphill.
“Putting air into the polymer was the way to do it.”
For more information, visit BirdieBall.com.
*This content is backed by the MyGolfSpy Integrity in Advertising Promise.
ZZ
3 weeks agoI’ve had mine for 3 years and am very satisfied. I ordered the public/municipal speed as some of the courses I frequented at the time had miserably slow greens. The public speed is not slow, and I have no complaints in regards to the pace of the putting mat.
In addition, the mat is very comfortable to stand on, feels like the “anti-fatigue mat” you might find in a kitchen or workshop. Can putt for hours if you have the time and desire.
I would agree, however, that the flagsticks are too light. Easily topple when struck.
Mg
4 weeks agoI have had my birdieball putting green for about 10 years. 18×4, 3 holes one end. I have used it almost daily, moved it from from Atlanta to Arizona to California. Mine is showing wear after 10 years, mostly do to dirt/ dust because I have had it in my garage in California versus inside the house in my other two locations. I occasionally vacuum it then brush it with a broom to return the grain to my liking. As a right handed golfer I would buy the two hole option because I want to stand on the putting green to put on a level stance. I agree with the comments about it being faster than advertised. It is very quick and the greens I play on are a 12 on the stimp. I use my BP putting green with the Dave Pelz putting tutor in my garage. Since I got the Putting Tutor training aid in September 2020 my handicap went from a 7.6 to a 5.6. I love both the BB putting green and the Putting Tutor.
JP
4 weeks agoI must have spent 3 months debating BB and Big Moss, both are by far the leaders of premier but affordable putting greens. I ended up with Big Moss because I needed something easier to roll up and store with multiple dogs around and family, and loved the idea of three hole sizes.
Couldn’t be more happy with the Big Moss, ended getting my brother one for his birthday and my dad one for christmas. That said, if I could have a dedicated space for practice where I could leave the matt installed I would certainly be interested in trying the BB, there is something really copelling about the idea of “grain” and not having a sewn pattern of a textile putting surface.
impressive that what started as a short flight plastic ball has turned into one of the top 3 practice green companies! very cool stuff
Nevin
1 month agoI had one and it was a very good putting green. Unfortunately the cat destroyed it almost immediately. Cat claws very quickly make it bumpy and not useful for putting. Too bad.
BTaylor
1 month agoIt’s interesting to hear all the comments about the speed being too fast as I read similar comments on an earlier article “THE BEST INDOOR PUTTING MATS FOR 2020”. After reading about the speed issues from other owners I went with a putting mat from Big Moss and it’s been awesome.
brianwhosoever
4 weeks agoTotally agreed. Did a lot of research on these before deciding to go with Big Moss. Feel like Big Moss is a higher quality, heavier duty, more durable, more consistent green than what is featured here. I have none of the issues posted here and am completely satisfied with my purchase. My putting has improved as well.
Dave C
1 month agoHi Todd,
I’ve had mine for five years. I went with the “medium” speed, that’s what it was called then. Anyways, my mat is on my concrete basement floor and i have a small square of the cabinet shelf liner that people put for friction/air on plates and cups. This provides some cushion to the ball and no issues with the ball bouncing out of the cup, with the birdieball “pin”.
Jeb Horton
1 month agoI’ve worked my way through four different matts. The BB was #3. If you’ve got a cat, good luck. Mine started to look ripped up after 24 hours. I velcroed a cover for it, but that’s a hassle. Matt #4 is more durable.
Kansas King
1 month agoI’ve had a BB mat for over a year and I believe they are the best rolling mats you can buy. However, I would suggest everyone buy the slowest mat possible as even it is very fast. I don’t know what these mats actually read on the stimpmeter but I have a hard time believing the slow one is actually only a 9. If anything, I would like an even slower mat because after practicing on the mat it is a challenge to reacquaint myself with the greens on my course which I wouldn’t call “slow”. Beyond that, I love the mat and have yet to find a mat the rolls remotely similar. I purchased the cheaper mat that is narrow and has one hole on each end and I’m satisfied. I thought about dropping some extra cash and getting a wider mat but I’m glad I didn’t. You can level out the narrow mat easily with little shims cut out of cardboard I’ve considered actually gluing the mat to a level piece of plywood with adjustable feet so I can use it wherever I want and make and on whatever surface I want. There really isn’t much of a reason to get the wide version as you then have to stand on it and made indentations with your feet everywhere.
M Scott
1 month agoI’ve had my BB for about three weeks. I got the 3′ x 12′ with two holes on one side and one hole on the other. I agree it is the best putting green available. I concur with the earlier comment, the speed of a “private course” green against the grain is crazy fast, down grain is like a table top. If I had a do-over I’d opt for the “public course” green speed.
EasyPutter
1 month agoThe BirdieBall PuttUp mats we tested in September and October were the fast speed 4×10 size. I think we all requested the middle speed to be similar to the greens on our courses but the company sent the fast ones because they believed the speed would allow the balls to return automatically that don’t go into the cups, and they did for the most part. Check out the official review and see the photos, videos and writeups from the six testers and some of the innovative ideas we had while objectively assessing what I believe is a top quality golf product.
Dave
1 month agoI really like my BB putting mat. I use it almost daily. My observations about it are:
– the grain isn’t just front to back
– it can bulge/potato chip due to temperature and humidity
– if you stand in the same area all the time, it will get permanently compressed.
– the flag bases could be heavier
– I had to epoxy the flags into the bases.
JimO
1 month agoI got the BB as a selfie gift for Christmas.. Here are my comments after using it for a month. Overall pretty pleased. As this article and the MGS review said it does roll well. I probably should have opted for the slower version as maybe once in the last 5 years my course has been as fast – no complaints with that, though. I have experienced the matt drift that was mentioned also. It moves from walking and putting on it. I actually slid the back bumpers off a bit so they extend 6 inches or so to keep it from moving back to the wall all the time. I am going to look into velcro as was suggested somewhere. It also doesn’t seem to want to lay perfectly flat so that I am playing 6 inches of break on a 6 foot putt. I can shim it somewhat so that’s not a big deal. Besides very few of my putts at the course are perfectly flat either. I wish I would have gone at least 2 feet longer. What I didn’t think about (which is on me I understand) is the that holes are cut about a foot in from the edge so that shortens the putts to about 6 feet when you get a stance. Statistically if you make all your six footers you’ll do well so there is a lot of room for me to get better.. Also for what it is worth I got it cut with 2 holes on one side and 1 centered on the other. I end up having to start in front of the holes on the 2 hole side so I am not stepping on the plastic cup liner so it is really 6 feet one way and 5 the other. I would opt for 1 on each side if I did it again unless I went with a wider matt but that is minor. And lastly an incredibly picky thing – I would like it if the flag bases (see picture above) were heavier. They tip over very easily. I think I’ll put that old lead tape to use somehow. And lastly – and this is absolutely not a critique just something to keep in mind if your situation is the same as mine – it is susceptible to cat claw marks. I’ve stopped him from the straight clawing but if he runs across in in a “cat rip”, like cats are know to do, his claws with leave marks. It has not really impacted the roll but you can see them. Indoor spike marks I guess. Here’s to better putting in ’21.
Todd Abraham
1 month agoI also bought the Birdie Ball putting green and to be honest I am not happy with it. The aesthetics, size, quality of materials and ease of assembly are all good but the speed makes it useless. I asked for the “private course” equivalent but it is outrageously fast…. well above the 11-12 my club usually rolls at…… its faster than the Riviera greens were in a pro-am and those were glass. Also, the regular hole inserts make it so only a really dying putt stay in the hole…. combine with the crazy speed I find it basically useless.
Greg
1 month agojimo, what width and speed did you get?
JimO
1 month agoI went with the 3 x 8. When I was planning the purchase I thought of a 4×8 sheet of plywood and thought that was too big. In retrospect I don’t think that. Measure your space and go absolutely as big as you can fit. Realize though that you can’t stand tight up against a wall on any of the sides so you don’t necessarily have to try for a wall to wall fit. Now I would go 3×10 or maybe even 3×12 but that is all the room I have.. I can’t go wider where I have it, or I would.