This year’s best game-improvement irons test featured 17 models. After analyzing the data on distance, accuracy and forgiveness, the clear standout was the Tour Edge Exotics E723. On the other end of the spectrum, the Wilson Dynapower irons finished in last place. However, there’s an interesting twist to this story that’s worth exploring further.
Distance
It’s no secret that golfers shopping for game-improvement irons expect to get more distance from a new set. Even golfers who claim not to care about distance still do. Distance is a key part of the sport.
You might be surprised to learn that the Wilson Dynapower was the longest iron in the 2024 test.
Yes, the golf iron that produced the most distance also had the worst overall finish in the test. When improving your game, accuracy is ultimately more crucial than distance, so keep that in mind.
While the Tour Edge Exotics was not the top performer in distance, it secured a solid fifth place overall. Getting a professional fitting can often help address issues with distance and improve overall performance.
Accuracy
We are done with the surprises at this point.
When it comes to accuracy and forgiveness, the Tour Edge stands out as the better iron than the Wilson Dynapower. The Tour Edge earned fourth place overall for accuracy.
To determine the top iron for accuracy, we use Strokes Gained as the metric. The idea is that we want the accuracy of the irons to save strokes on the course.
The iron with the most accuracy in the 2024 test was the MacGregor MACSPD. Interestingly, it was also the shortest iron of the test. We will let you figure that one out for yourself.
The Wilson Dynapower landed in 15th place for accuracy. Not a strong showing.
You’ll have to decide if distance is truly what is keeping you from shooting lower golf scores. For most players, it is not.
Forgiveness
The last major category for our game-improvement iron testing is forgiveness. When we test for forgiveness, we look at consistency in the shot outcomes.
Do the irons offer one perfect shot followed by three terrible shots? This consistency or forgiveness metric is very important for the game-improvement category.
Most golfers with game-improvement irons in the bag know they can’t repeat the same swing every time. When a golf iron can step in and give you results that are both consistent and reliable, it deserves to win best game-improvement iron of 2024.
The Tour Edge Exotics E723 is the most forgiving iron in the 2024 test while the Wilson Dynapower is the least forgiving.
Value
The Tour Edge Exotics irons are $799. The Wilson Dynapower retails for $699. The $100 difference between first- and last-place performance should not be the most difficult decision.
However, if your only goal in purchasing new irons is to gain distance, you’ll like what the Wilson Dynapower offers. Going for a fitting where you test both irons should help you narrow down the best fit for your game.
The bottom line
The longest iron in game improvement did not earn the top spot in our 2024 testing. It earned last place. Yes, we weigh the test based on accuracy which is the most important factor in golf iron performance. Do you want to save shots or not?
At some point in your golf career, you’ll have to decide which performance type is the most important for your game.
Tour Edge versus Wilson: Which is right for you?
Who’s it For?
✅ Someone looking for more forgiveness. The most forgiving game-improvement iron of 2024.
✅ The golfer who cares about accuracy. With a fourth-place overall finish for accuracy, the Tour Edge can save strokes on the course.
Who’s it not for?
❌ Not the shortest iron in the test but not the longest. If you seek maximum distance, try something else.
❌ Some testers found the thicker top line to be the biggest negative to the Tour Edge irons.
Who’s it For?
✅ Players looking for more distance. The longest iron in the 2024 test.
✅ Golfers on a budget: For $699, the Wilson Dynapower is one of the more affordable golf irons in the test.
Who’s it not for?
❌ Anyone who needs accuracy on the course may struggle with the Wilson Dynapower performance.
❌ The least forgiving game-improvement iron of 2024. A golfer who lacks consistency may have difficulty with the Dynapower.
Dules
2 years ago
I am using the least forgiving iron- the Dynapowers steel KBS Tour lite shafts- with the worst golf ball ever tested – Snell 3.0 – and my handicap has lowered from 10.2 to 5.4 across 70 rounds to date in 2024 from the tees I normally play – 5700 yards. 69 yrs old & losing swing speed & hairline rapidly.
I thought MYGOLFSPY was the Bible of gear testing but starting to lose my faith. Maybe the testers are too good for some of the clubs they test?