First Versus Worst Player’s Irons 2025 (What’s The Difference?)

In our 2025 Most Wanted Player’s Iron test, we evaluated 22 models across three key metrics: accuracy, distance, forgiveness. With more than 21,000 shots hit, the Srixon ZXi7 came out on top while the PXG 0317 CB finished dead last. Here’s how the best player’s iron of 2025 stacks up against the worst.

What do these irons have in common?

Even though the Srixon ZXi7 was our top performer and the PXG 0317 CB finished last, they still share several design features that better players look for.

• Tour-Inspired shape: Both irons have a compact shape with a thin topline and minimal offset.
• Forged construction: Each set is fully forged to improve feel and deliver consistent feedback.
• Groove technology: They both feature groove technology designed for the better player. Srixon uses progressive grooves and laser milling. PXG designs its grooves for high spin and control into the greens.
• Custom fitting available: Both are offered with custom shaft, grip and loft options so you can dial in performance.

What makes the Srixon ZXi7 so much better?

The Srixon ZXi7 is the best-performing player’s iron of 2025. It finished first overall in our test by excelling in accuracy and forgiveness. While accuracy is probably the most important for golfers shopping for players’ irons, forgiveness matters as well. Srixon performed across the board.

Its accuracy score (9.5/10) was the highest in the test, helping golfers hit more greens and find tighter dispersion. It also had the highest forgiveness score (9.6). We measure forgiveness by looking for iron consistency and the Srixon ZXi7 delivered.

PXG’s 0317 CB, on the other hand, finished last overall. While it wasn’t the worst in every category, it lagged in forgiveness and accuracy.

Srixon also ranked high in subjective categories like sound, feel and looks. PXG’s CB model didn’t generate the same confidence or feedback during testing. If you care about performance over branding, the Srixon ZXi7 should be at the top of your list.

Which one is the better value?

When it comes to player’s irons, value isn’t about finding the cheapest set: it’s about performance. In this case, the pricing is close enough that it shouldn’t factor into your decision.

The Srixon ZXi7 performs better. The PXG 0317 CB doesn’t. That’s why, regardless of the price tag, the ZXi7 is the better value.

Don’t see what you are looking for?

If neither of these irons fits your golf game or your budget, look at our complete Best Player’s Iron Testing.