Support our Mission. We independently test each product we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.
Wedges are the most versatile golf clubs. Other than a putter, perhaps, they are also the most personal for you creative short-game wizards. So determining the best wedges of 2024 would be a daunting task. Unless it’s MyGolfSpy, the industry leader in independent golf club evaluation, doing the testing. Our testing results are backed by more than a decade of experience.
Our 2024 Wedge Test is an in-depth analysis of some of the hottest names in golf. This year’s test features 26 wedge models from the biggest names in golf along with smaller brands vying for your attention and dollars.
In total, our testing team spent more than 200 hours collecting and analyzing data from a test pool of 20 avid golfers just like you. To identify the best wedges, we evaluate accuracy, consistency and spin metrics. This varies from our usual scoring categories of accuracy, distance and forgiveness.
The results of this test serve as an indispensable guide for the off-the-rack buyer or for anyone looking for a bit of extra insight before your next fitting. Whatever you’re looking for from your next wedge, you’ll find it here.
These are the best wedges of 2024.
Wedge performance should be predictable and reliable in all playing conditions. The best wedges provide excellent performance across all three of our scoring categories – accuracy, consistency and spin.
We’ve included subjective feedback from our testers. However, it does not factor in the rankings. Performance should always trump opinion when it comes to purchasing a new golf club. Backed by more than a decade of golf club testing experience, we can confidently state that popular opinion doesn’t always match reality.
These are the best wedges overall.
Review Score
Accuracy
Distance Score
Forgiveness
Price
Once again, PING excels in our wet condition testing. PING actually produces more spin when moisture is present. It produces a high spin rate across all testing conditions, which makes it the best wedge for spin in 2024. If you play in a variety of conditions, PING S159 is worth considering.
Not only is PING S159 the best wedge for spin, it is a top-tier performer for accuracy and consistency. Wedges are scoring clubs and hitting shots near or around the pin is critical to lower scores. In our wedge testing, consistency is measuring how well a wedge produces tight carry distances and dispersion. This is important because we test in a full-swing and a 50-yard distance.
Frankly, the only reason you aren't giving this wedge at least a try is because you don't like PING wedges. Fair enough. That is the subjective part of golf. Based on performance, PING S159 should be a wedge you at least demo.
PING S159 is the best wedge of 2024. Our wedge testing analyzes accuracy, consistency and spin. S159 ranks fifth for accuracy, third for consistency and first for spin. Wedge testing is different than other Most Wanted tests. It includes a full-swing condition and a 50-yard condition where moisture is present. For years, PING’s wedges perform when moisture is present. In most cases, we’ve seen the spin be higher in wet conditions. If you want a wedge that performs in all conditions, PING S159 might be the golden ticket.
“Looks and feel are really good.”
“Familiar, comfortable, and solid performance across the board.”
“Pleasantly surprised. I’ve hit them before but these are much better. They’ve improved their wedge game.”
PING’s wedges always impress for spin in wet conditions. But, across the board, they’ve underwhelmed for accuracy and consistency. PING S159 finally addresses these performance issues and excels in all three scoring categories. It is the best for spin, and it also produces accuracy and consistency from all three of our testing conditions. Subjectively, this is one of the better PING wedges in some time according to our testers. Go check it out.
Review Score
Accuracy
Distance Score
Forgiveness
Price
In our wedge testing, accuracy is based on Strokes Gained across our two testing conditions: full swing and 50 yards. TaylorMade Milled Grind 4 finishes second overall for accuracy. Wedges are scoring clubs. Thus, Strokes Gained and performance are paramount when you have a wedge in your hand. Shots that are near or around the pin consistently will help you in the long run and MG4 excels with this.
If you've been following Most Wanted testing, you know consistency generally correlates to how we score and analyze forgiveness. In wedge testing, consistency is assessing how well a wedge produces carry distances and dispersion. With a wedge, golfers are hitting an array of different shots: full shots, pitches and chips. Our testing includes full swings and 50-yard shots. Across these two conditions, MG4 performs. If you want reliability and distance control, MG4 is worth trying.
When you think of wedges, TaylorMade probably isn't the first name you think of. However, over the past several years, their wedges have dominated our wedge testing. It is time to consider TaylorMade as one of the top wedge manufacturers, especially with the performance of Milled Grind 4.
TaylorMade Milled Grind 4 is still one of the best wedge options on the market. Top to bottom, it performs as it is one of the best wedges for accuracy and consistency. These two scoring categories is where we see it shine. For spin, it takes a bit of a hit since there are new competitors in the field. However, it still places ninth overall for our spin scoring category. TaylorMade continues to impress in the wedge space. If you haven’t tried one, you need to check it out.
“Subjectively, I like it more than the other wedges in the test.”
“Like the looks. They grab your attention.”
“Solid overall. It is one of the wedges that definitely has my interest.”
“One of the best wedges and it has a great profile.”
Over the past few years, TaylorMade has pushed their wedge performance to a top-tier level. This is the first year TaylorMade’s Milled Grind wedge hasn’t won a Most Wanted test in some time. However, it is still a top performer. Accuracy and consistency are the two categories it thrives in. Spin across the board is solid and it does a fair job of retaining spin in wet conditions. It is a wedge to check out.
Review Score
Accuracy
Distance Score
Forgiveness
Price
Titleist Vokey SM10 is the best wedge for accuracy. This means it produces the best Strokes Gained across the entire test. In our test, we hit wedge shots from two conditions: full swing and 50 yards. A wedge needs to have playability and produce tight proximity to the hole. If your wedge doesn't perform, it is costing you strokes. Titleist Vokey SM10 performs in the scoring category that might be the most important.
From a performance standpoint, Titleist Vokey SM10 is superb. It swept our subjective feedback categories, too. It is rated as the best wedge for looks, feel, sound and likelihood of purchase by our 20 testers.
Nowadays, most wedges are $179.99. Titleist pushes the envelope and comes in at $189.99. It isn't the most expensive wedge on the market, but it certainly isn't price friendly.
Titleist Vokey wedges are a household name. Most golfers are familiar with these wedges. They haven’t always performed well, especially in our wet condition. However, Vokey SM10 is one of the best overall wedges for 2024. It ranks third overall and is the best wedge for accuracy. Additionally, it places in the top 10 for consistency and spin.
“The feel stands out over other wedges.”
“Great feel and checks off all the boxes.”
“The standard.”
“Subjectively, I love it. However, the weighting is too heavy, which I don’t like.”
Titleist Vokey SM10 cleans house with subjective feedback awards, which is a testament to its popularity. Performance speaks for itself as it is the best wedge for accuracy in our testing and one of the best across the board.
Accuracy should be your No. 1 priority in a wedge. Hitting the green with a wedge is paramount. It is a scoring club in your golf bag. When you’re in range of the green with a wedge, the expectation should be to be reasonably close to the hole.
These are the best wedges for accuracy.
Review Score
Accuracy
Distance Score
Forgiveness
Price
Titleist Vokey SM10 is the best wedge for accuracy. This means it produces the best Strokes Gained across the entire test. In our test, we hit wedge shots from two conditions: full swing and 50 yards. If your wedge doesn't perform, it is likely costing you strokes. Titleist Vokey SM10 performs in the scoring category that might be the most important.
From a performance standpoint, Titleist Vokey SM10 is superb. It swept our subjective feedback categories, too. It is rated as the best wedge for looks, feel, sound and likelihood of purchase by our 20 testers.
Nowadays, most wedges are $179.99. Titleist pushes the envelope and comes in at $189.99. It isn't the most expensive wedge on the market, but it certainly isn't price friendly.
Titleist Vokey wedges are a household name. Most golfers are familiar with these wedges. They haven’t always performed well, especially in our wet condition. However, Vokey SM10 is one of the best overall wedges for 2024. It ranks third overall and is the best wedge for accuracy. Additionally, it places in the top 10 for consistency and spin.
“The feel stands out over other wedges.”
“Great feel and checks off all the boxes.”
“The standard.”
“Subjectively, I love it. However, the weighting is too heavy, which I don’t like.”
Titleist Vokey SM10 cleans house with subjective feedback awards, which is a testament to its popularity. It is the best wedge for accuracy in our testing and one of the best across the board.
Review Score
Accuracy
Distance Score
Forgiveness
Price
In our wedge testing, accuracy is based on Strokes Gained across our two testing conditions: full swing and 50 yards. TaylorMade Milled Grind 4 finishes second overall for accuracy. Shots that are near or around the pin consistently will help you in the long run and MG4 excels with this.
If you've been following Most Wanted testing, you know consistency generally correlates to how we score and analyze forgiveness. In wedge testing, "consistency" is assessing how well a wedge produces carry distances and dispersion. With a wedge, golfers are hitting an array of different shots: full shots, pitches, and chips. Our testing includes full swings and 50-yard shots. Across these two conditions, MG4 performs. If you want reliability and essentially distance control, MG4 is worth trying.
When you think of wedges, TaylorMade probably isn't the first name you think of. However, over the past several years, their wedges have dominated our wedge testing. It is time to consider TaylorMade as one of the top wedge manufacturers, especially with the performance of Milled Grind 4.
TaylorMade Milled Grind 4 is still one of the best wedge options on the market. Top to bottom, it is one of the best wedges for accuracy and consistency. These two scoring categories are where we see it shine. For spin, it takes a bit of a hit since there are new competitors in the fold. However, it still places ninth overall for our spin scoring category. TaylorMade continues to impress in the wedge space. If you haven’t tried one, you need to check it out.
“Subjectively, I like it more than the other wedges in the test.”
“Like the looks. They grab your attention.”
“Solid overall. It is one of the wedges that definitely has my interest.”
Over the past few years, TaylorMade is one of the top name manufacturers to push their wedge performance to a new, top tier level. This is the first year TaylorMade’s Milled Grind wedge hasn’t won a Most Wanted test in some time. However, it is still a top performer. Accuracy and consistency are the two categories it thrives in. Spin across the board is solid and it does a fair job of retaining spin in wet conditions. It is a wedge to check out.
Consistency is a vital part to anyone’s golf game. More importantly, it is a performance trait that can make or break a wedge’s performance. Our testing features three testing conditions: full swing, 50-yard dry and 50-yard wet. Wedges that showcase consistency offer reliable distance control throughout these testing conditions.
These are the best wedges for consistency.
Review Score
Distance Score
Accuracy
Forgiveness
Price
Consistency with any golf club is important. As a golfer, you want to feel confident about the shot outcome. This is even more true with a scoring club, i.e., a wedge. Sub 70 TAIII is the best wedge for consistency because it produces tight carry distance deltas and dispersion across our entire test.
Most wedges are $179.99 or more. However, Sub 70 TAIII is $125. This is a great bargain on a wedge that offers consistency and distance control.
Although Sub 70 TAIII produces tight carry distance deltas and overall dispersion. It does underwhelm for accuracy and spin. It is slightly below average for both scoring categories. On a positive note, TAIII does handle wet conditions fairly well and retains a high percentage of its spin.
Distance control and dispersion are critical ingredients to wedge performance. Sub 70 TAIII is the best wedge for consistency in our 2024 test. Our consistency category assesses carry consistency and dispersion area across the entire test. This accounts for all testing conditions – full-swing, 50-yards dry and 50-yards wet. Producing similar shot outcomes is important with a scoring club. If you prioritize this consistency, Sub 70 TAIII is worth testing.
“I like it. It has a unique profile and design to it, and the performance is solid.”
“It comes in a dark and chrome finish, which is great. Having those choices are nice and seem to be a consistent them throughout the industry.”
“For the price, you can’t beat it. I was especially surprised by its performance in wet conditions.”
Sub 70 TAIII won’t be your first wedge choice, your second or even third. However, for the price, it is certainly worth considering if you are price conscious. It is the best wedge for consistency, which means it produces tight carry distance deltas and dispersion throughout our testing conditions.
Review Score
Distance Score
Accuracy
Forgiveness
Price
If you've been following Most Wanted testing, you know consistency generally correlates to how we score and analyze forgiveness. In wedge testing, consistency is assessing how well a wedge produces carry distances and dispersion. With a wedge, golfers are hitting an array of different shots: full shots, pitches and chips. Our testing includes full swings and 50-yard shots. Across these two conditions, MG4 performs. If you want reliability and essentially distance control, MG4 is worth trying.
In our wedge testing, accuracy is based on Strokes Gained across our two testing conditions: full swing and 50 yards. TaylorMade Milled Grind 4 finishes second overall for accuracy. Shots that are near or around the pin consistently will help you in the long run and MG4 excels with this.
When you think of wedges, TaylorMade probably isn't the first name you think of. However, over the past several years, their wedges have dominated our wedge testing. It is time to consider TaylorMade as one of the top wedge manufacturers, especially with the performance of Milled Grind 4.
TaylorMade Milled Grind 4 is still one of the best wedge options on the market. Top to bottom, it is one of the best wedges for accuracy and consistency. These two scoring categories are where we see it shine. For spin, it takes a bit of a hit since there are new competitors in the field. However, it still places ninth overall for our spin scoring category. TaylorMade continues to impress in the wedge space. If you haven’t tried one, you need to check it out.
“Subjectively, I like it more than the other wedges in the test.”
“Like the looks. They grab your attention.”
“Solid overall. It is one of the wedges that definitely has my interest.”
“One of the best wedges and it has a great profile.”
Over the past few years, TaylorMade has pushed their wedge performance to the top tier. This is the first year TaylorMade’s Milled Grind wedge hasn’t won a Most Wanted test in some time. However, it is still a top performer. Accuracy and consistency are the two categories it thrives in. Spin across the board is solid and it does a fair job of retaining spin in wet conditions. It is a wedge to check out.
With wedges, spin might be the most important metric. In our testing, we capture spin in three different conditions: full swing, 50-yard dry and 50-yard wet. Each of these conditions plays a role in a wedge’s spin performance.
On full swings, most wedges produce similar spin numbers. Where we see the biggest separation is the spin retention rate when moisture is present. There are wedges that excel in this condition and there are wedges that are abysmal. Do not overlook this detail.
Below are the best wedges for spin.
Review Score
Accuracy
Distance Score
Forgiveness
Price
Once again, PING wedges excel in wet conditions, actually producing more spin when moisture is present. Additionally, it produces a high spin rate across all testing conditions, which makes it the best wedge for spin in 2024.
Not only is PING S159 the best wedge for spin, it is a top performer for accuracy and consistency. Wedges need to be accurate. They're a scoring club and hitting shots near or around the pin is critical to lower scores. In our wedge testing, "consistency" is measuring how well a wedge produces tight carry distances and dispersion. You need to have consistency and control from all distances when using a wedge.
If the only reason you aren't giving this wedge at least a try is because you don't like PING wedges, that's OK. That is the subjective part of golf. Based on performance, PING S159 should be a wedge you at least demo.
PING S159 is the best wedge of 2024. Our wedge testing analyzes accuracy, consistency, and spin. S159 ranks fifth for accuracy, third for consistency and first for spin. Wedge testing is different than other Most Wanted tests. It includes a full-swing condition and a 50-yard condition where moisture is present. In most cases, we’ve seen the spin from PING wedges be higher in wet conditions. If you want a wedge that performs in all conditions, PING S159 might be the golden ticket.
“Looks and feel are really good.”
“Familiar, comfortable, and solid performance across the board.”
“Pleasantly surprised. I’ve hit them before but these are much better. They’ve improved their wedge game.”
PING’s wedges always impress for spin in wet conditions. But, across the board, they’ve underwhelmed for accuracy and consistency. PING S159 finally addresses these performance issues and excels in all three scoring categories. It is the best for spin, and it also produces accuracy and consistency from all three of our testing conditions. Subjectively, this is one of the better PING wedges in some time according to our testers. Go check it out.
Review Score
Forgiveness
Distance Score
Accuracy
Price
Cleveland is one of the best wedge manufacturers for spin. RTX Full-Face 2 is the second-best wedge for spin in this year's test. Whether it is a full-swing, a 50-yard dry shot or 50-yard wet shot, spin consistency is RTX Full-Face 2's forte. Like PING, it produces more spin in a wet condition versus dry.
Yes, Cleveland RTX Full-Face 2 produces consistent spin performance across all of our testing conditions. However, it misses the mark in terms of accuracy and consistency. Accuracy is based on Strokes Gained across all testing conditions. Consistency is evaluating carry distance and dispersion across all testing conditions. Relative to the field, Cleveland RTX Full-Face 2 is below average.
Cleveland continues to make wedges that perform, especially in wet conditions. Cleveland RTX Full-Face 2 ranks second in our spin scoring category. One of the highlights is that it also spins more in wet conditions. Unfortunately, accuracy and consistency hurt RTX Full-Face 2’s performance, which means it has a poor Strokes Gained performance and didn’t produce tight carry distances and dispersion relative to the field.
“Well balanced, provides a “thump” like feel at impact. You can’t go wrong with a Cleveland wedge IMO.”
“Clean profile, however, I do not like the full-face aspect.”
Cleveland RTX Full-Face 2 is one of the best wedges for spin, especially in wet conditions. Performance in this scenario is Cleveland’s specialty. We continually see them perform at a high success rate in wet conditions and spin in general. However, this model misses the mark with accuracy and consistency.
Our mission is to cut through the subjective BS and encourage golfers to buy based on performance. Performance should be your top priority. However, there are other things you need to consider when purchasing a new wedge.
Every wedge in our test is 55-56 degrees in loft. However, for most golfers, that isn’t the only wedge in their golf bags. A good rule of thumb with your wedges is to have a gap of four to six degrees of loft between each wedge. Do you play a 56-degree sand wedge? Consider implementing a 52 degree gap wedge and 60 degree lob wedge on the bookends of it. Or, if you play a 54 (which is becoming more popular), consider a 50 and 58.
This leaves you with an ideal setup and some spacing in your wedge lofts.
Regardless, ensuring that your yardages are dialed and that you have the proper loft can lead to better scoring opportunities, more distance control and, ultimately, lower scores.
Wedge grind can get confusing, and when you are looking for the best golf wedges, you’ll want to consider everything from loft to bounce to grind, etc. Grind is the shaping of the sole of the wedge, mostly in the areas of the heel, toe, and trailing edge.
The grind affects how the club interacts with the turf (or sand). Grind will help you adjust to playing in firm conditions or when the golf course is soft. If you want a few simple rules of thumb on how to choose grind, use these:
Want a more detailed guide about wedge grinds – here is our guide on Wedge Grinds Explained.
You’ll even see professionals put a different shaft in their wedges than in their irons. Part of the benefit of going for a fitting is to dial in the wedge shafts. Even Scottie Scheffler plays the Dynamic Gold Tour Issue X100 in the irons and the S400 in the wedges.
At one point it was thought that a high handicapper should only play with cavity back style wedges and leave the blades to the professionals. However, golfers of all abilities are learning that spin performance and distance control are much more important than the style of the wedge.
The most important thing is having the control you need to hit square faced shots that end up close to the pin. Don’t push the PING or the Titleist Vokey or Taylormade to the side because you worry about forgiveness. Test them and see the difference the spin and accuracy can have on your game.
Pricing will always impact a purchasing decision. When it comes to price, wedges are a mixed bag. Your household names (Mizuno, Titleist, Callaway etc.) stretch the pricing to $179 to $189. Some exceed $200 for a golf wedge. There are some bargains to be had, though. Take Sub 70 TAIII. It is the best wedge for consistency and you can get your hands on it for $125.
Our 2024 Most Wanted test took 200 testing hours. For 2024, the testing pool included 26 different wedge models.
MyGolfSpy’s test program is powered by four crucial components :
Wedge testing included 20 testers of varying skill levels. Our testing featured three conditions: full-swing shots, 50-yard dry shots and 50-yard wet shots. Each participating wedge is hit from these three testing conditions.
For the 50-yard wet shots, moisture is added to the equation by spraying the hitting surface (ground) and applying water to the golf ball. To eliminate variables, the face of the wedge is dried between each shot.
Providing you, the golfer and consumer, with insights into the best wedges on the market is our No. 1 goal with this test. We can’t do that without taking a diligent, in-depth approach to analyzing the data we collect throughout this process.
Our scoring categories for wedges are slightly different than other Most Wanted tests. We will review these below. However, we are taking a more extensive approach to our scoring categories.
Overall scores are now labeled as an MGS Score.
Wedge testing is comprised of three scoring categories:
These three categories are weighted with accuracy taking priority.
Accuracy is a game-changer. Hitting the green or close to your intended target leads to better scores. This is even more critical for wedges. For our accuracy category, we analyze one specific metric:
With a wedge, consistency is important. You want reliable distance control with your scoring golf clubs. For consistency, we evaluate these metrics:
Spin is one of the most important metrics for wedges. In this category specifically, it is where we see a clear distinction between good and poor wedges. In wet conditions, performance changes drastically. Good wedges will retain spin and mitigate launch. Poor wedges will lose spin and increase launch. For our spin category, we asses four specific metrics:
Scores are derived from the key metrics above with specific weighting going into each scoring category. For us, accuracy is always of utmost importance and is weighted the most. However, for wedges, we put slightly more emphasis on spin performance versus consistency.
For wedges, golfers should prioritize overall performance. Accuracy, spin and consistency all matter. The best wedges perform in all three of these areas.
One of the key performance differences in a wedge is spin retention when moisture is present. The best wedges retain spin well or even, spin more when exposed to moisture.
The overall score is derived from the three scoring categories: accuracy, spin and consistency.
| Product | Overall Rank | Accuracy Rank | Consistency Rank | Spin Rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PING S159 | 1st | 5th | 3rd | 1st |
| TaylorMade Milled Grind 4 | 2nd | 2nd | 2nd | 9th |
| Titleist Vokey SM10 | 3rd | 1st | 6th | 10th |
| COBRA Snakebite X | 4th | 3rd | 5th | 16th |
| Cleveland CBX Full-Face 2 | 5th | 10th | 11th | 4th |
| Cleveland RTX6 ZipCore | 6th | 6th | 12th | 6th |
| Mizuno T24 | 7th | 4th | 15th | 15th |
| PXG Sugar Daddy III | 8th | 12th | 8th | 8th |
| Tour Edge Exotics Wingman | 9th | 8th | 16th | 12th |
| Edison Golf 2.0 | 10th | 14th | 17th | 7th |
| Cleveland CBX4 ZipCore | 11th | 16th | 18th | 3rd |
| Sub 70 TAIII | 12th | 17th | 1st | 14th |
| COBRA Snakebite | 13th | 19th | 4th | 5th |
| Wilson Staff Model HT | 14th | 15th | 9th | 13th |
| Toura Golf F-SPEC | 15th | 11th | 14th | 22nd |
| Tommy Armour 845+ CB | 16th | 9th | 21st | 21st |
| Callaway OPUS Platinum | 17th | 13th | 19th | 18th |
| Tommy Armour 845+ Milled | 18th | 7th | 23rd | 23rd |
| Cleveland RTX Full-Face 2 | 19th | 23rd | 22nd | 2nd |
| TaylorMade MG4 Hi-Toe | 20th | 20th | 10th | 19th |
| Bettinardi HLX 5.0 | 21st | 21st | 13th | 17th |
| Wilson Staff Model | 22nd | 26th | 7th | 11th |
| Smithworks X-Spin | 23rd | 18th | 25th | 26th |
| Callaway OPUS | 24th | 22nd | 26th | 20th |
| New Level SPN-VS | 25th | 24th | 20th | 24th |
| Vice Golf VGW01 | 26th | 25th | 24th | 25th |
World-class testing requires world-class equipment. This is the gear we trust to help us fulfill our Most Wanted testing.
Cancer Survivor. Amputee Golfer. Essentially, a OneLeggedBoss. When he isn't facilitating testing or analyzing data, Phillip enjoys his family time, practicing and playing golf, unwinding with video games, capturing photos of nature, or devouring pretzels.
| Driver Titleist TSR3 | 3 Wood Titleist TSR3 |
| Driving Iron Titleist U505 | Irons (5-6) Titleist T200 |
| Irons (7-PW) Titleist T150 | Wedges (50, 56, 60) Titleist Vokey SM10 |
| Putter L.A.B. Mezz.1 Max | Ball Titleist Pro V1x |
5 months ago
I play the Edison wedges and I love them. I have fit before but it did not include turf interaction which I think is most important. My course has tight lies and the Edison wedges are terrific for those conditions
6 months ago
So much for Opus changing the wedge game. Woof!
6 months ago
No mention of Edel wedges? Can’t imagine them not stacking up quite favorably vs. any of the competition. Understand they’re a boutique DTC company, but what a tragic omission. They are top shelf weapons.
6 months ago
Agreed
5 months ago
in my bag and i am shocked they are not on the list. they are fantastic
6 months ago
My greatest need from a wedge is turf interaction and versatility. I prefer to play wedges with the lowest reasonable bounce and I like toe and heel relief. Of course an issue is turf conditions and how they vary course to course but for me seasonally. My swing speed is to low to generate “Tourlike” spin on full shots but several have commented to me that my pitch and chip shots checkup more than they expected. I use Vokey wedges because of the different grinds available. For my 46/50/54 I stay with the same wedges but for my 58 I change between the T/L/M grinds. Just personal preference. Of the wedges I have demoed I would not rate any as “better”. I have noticed some non-Titleist TOUR players using Vokeys. I guess you would have to ask them why.
6 months ago
The grind versatility is what drives the Vokey’s to the top of the list when shopping for wedges for me. I feel like they’re all going to spin about the same and have the same “accuracy”.
6 months ago
Are there any details around the spin RPM results for each wedge from the distances measures (full swing, 50 dry, 50 wet, dry vs. wet retention)?
Asking because individual rankings have ping at #1 and vokey at #10. Vokey has better rankings in both accuracy and consistency so, aside from private compensation, the spin number is visible reason why Ping is ranked #1.
Is the difference between #1 and #10 for spin a meaningful amount and how are the weights broken down between accuracy, consistency and spin? I would think spin #s are irrelevant if the club doesn’t consistently land the ball in the expected area.
6 months ago
Question on the Wilson Wedges. The 2024 model for Wilson is the Staff Model ZM and Staff Model ZM HT. Without the ZM, it indicates perhaps the previous model was tested. Can you please confirm which on was included in this test?
6 months ago
I’ve felt for years the TM MG series were the top wedges available and played MG 2,3, and 4 but recently switched to the super forgiving, super skinny Hi Toes…IMHO, the Hi Toe 4 are the best they’ve ever made and should be #1 on your rank list. Surprised they finished so far below in ranking at #20 from the regular MG series. I urge EVERYONE to give them a try !
6 months ago
RE: Sub 70 TA III wedge
Another reason to not look at these, they are not available if you are left-handed. I’m sure all of your testers are right-handed, but since you have the information, please state if it is not available left-handed or has limited availability such as only 52*, 56* & 60*.
6 months ago
I’ll keep playing my Cleveland’s
6 months ago
Cleveland wedges are some of the best year to year.
6 months ago
Could someone at MGS expand on the real world differences between the Accuracy and Consistency metrics? It would seem this would go hand in hand, a club that performs the same over and over would then lead to it being more accurate. Yet there are many results where this two rankings are no where near one another.
6 months ago
Accuracy is strictly strokes gained across the entire test. It is not proximity to the hole alone. There are methodologies in place, but it is evaluating how each wedge performs relative to all of the other wedges, especially in a full-swing scenario. Consistency is carry distance and dispersion. Just like any other golf club, there are differences in how consistent a wedge is at producing carry distance deltas (the difference between its longest and shortest shot). Dispersion is a double-edge sword and unfortunately, it is often perceived as good accuracy. Dispersion can be tight AND inaccurate simultaneously. Hence, why some wedges are great for consistency, but average to below average for accuracy.
6 months ago
Thanks Phillip, I appreciate you clarifying!
6 months ago
They can be related and go hand in hand but can also differentiate too. It’s the classic precision vs accuracy. You can consistently hit the same yardage and still be “X” yards away from the target while another has more variable yardage yet be closer to the targets overall.
I have issues with one hitting on mats for a wedge test and secondly no specifics on how they use strokes gained. Like does everyone hit to the same hole? And what is the target handicap that they use for the strokes gained? a scratch or 10 handi? That actually those skews numbers based on who you compare it to.
6 months ago
I dont understand why accuracy isnt the only criteria for top wedge. i dont see an entry for spin on my scorecard. Spin rolls up into accuracy.
6 months ago
I agree with you completely!
6 months ago
I’ve holed out with Cleveland Wedges 3:1 lifetime and that’s facts. Hint hint: YOU DONT NEED 3;WEDGES!! YOU DEFINITELY DONT NEED 4. I love to see the guys at my club pull that 69 around the fringe, square that face (not open), and lay the sod right over that ball! Just guessing 99% of players who game a 60 would gain +-2 strokes a round if they left it at home. I’m playing Zipcore Raw 52 Mid, 58 Mid AND 64 Full Face LOW. I have delusions oh Phil with that 64 but come at me and I’m getting up and down. Might just dunk it. Give me Roger Cleveland Wedges. You can keep Bob Vokey and his 50 grinds and TaylorMade (I want like to open hand slap lil Rory). These are the facts of life. Hahaha Cheers boys!
5 months ago
TRUE!
6 months ago
I got fitted into the Ping S159’s back in July and I absolutely love them! The fitter had me hit the S10 Vokey’s, TaylorMade MG4’s, and Cleveland RTX, and it was a no brainer for the fitter to set me up with the S159’s. I had a tighter dispersion and a higher and more consistent spin rate with the S159’s.
Bob Kirkwood
2 weeks ago
You test direct to consumer brands. I would like to see you include Maltby offerings. I’m sure you are familiar with them. You can order as components of have clubs custom assembled to you exact specifications.