Best Mallet Putters 2023
Putters

Best Mallet Putters 2023

Support our Mission. We independently test each product we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

Best Mallet Putters 2023
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
L.A.B. Golf Mezz.1 Max
Bettinardi Studio Stock 16
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
2023 Most Wanted
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
  • Best Mallet 2023
  • Best for sound
  • Best from 10 and 20 feet
  • Below average performance from five feet
  • Average for feel
  • 96.64
Runner Up
LAB Golf Mezz.1 Max
L.A.B. Golf Mezz.1 Max
  • Top-five finish from 10 and 20 feet
  • Rates well for sound
  • Below average for feel and looks
  • 89.62
Best from 5 Feet
Bettinardi Studio Stock 16
Bettinardi Studio Stock 16
  • Best from five feet
  • Above average rating for looks
  • Average for feel and sound
  • Below average from 20 feet
  • 85.86
Best from 10 Feet
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
  • Best from 10 feet
  • Available in a double-bend profile
  • Average for feel
  • 96.64
Best from 20 Feet
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S
  • Best from 20 feet
  • Features Stroke Lab putter shaft
  • Below average performance from five feet
  • 96.64

Our Job Is Your Game

The most comprehensive review of the best mallet putters of 2023 is here.

Here at MyGolfSpy, we are committed to providing data-driven product reviews. For this Most Wanted Test, 20 testers each hit eight putts from five, 10 and 20 feet with each participating mallet putter model.

Use this review to help guide you with your next putter purchase. It is indispensable.

Best Mallet Putter 2023: Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S

Bottom Line

Odyssey mallet putters continue to perform well in our Most Wanted Mallet tests. The Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S dominates the field to claim the title of Best Mallet Putter 2023. It excels from 10 and 20 feet so it’s no wonder it earned the top spot.

Technology

Available with a short slant neck the Tri-Hot 5K features multi-material front loaded tungsten weighting design that improves CG (center of gravity) positioning and overall forgiveness. It also features the Odyssey White Hot Face Insert for improved feel and consistency. Finally the dual colour and white dual and triple lines all act as visual alignment aids. With the triple lines being the same width as the Callaway Triple-Track featured golf ball.

Pros

Putting from 10 and 20 feet is where this mallet shines. Ultimately, these are the distances that lead to its massive victory.

Cons

Below average performance from five feet and it rates just average for feel.

Who Is It For?

Since it features toe-hang properties, the Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S will suit golfers with an arcing putting stroke.

Tester Feedback

  • Best for sound
  • Rates highly for looks and likelihood of purchase

Best Mallet Putters Overall

TOP PICKS: ODYSSEY TRI-HOT 5K ROSSIE S, L.A.B. GOLF MEZZ.1 MAX, EVNROLL EV5

Observations

  • Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S is your Best Mallet Putter 2023 based on its strong performance from 10 and 20 feet.
  • L.A.B. Golf Mezz.1 Max finishes second, performing consistently from all three testing distances.
  • Evnroll EV5 narrowly places third behind Mezz.1 Max. One of the best mallet putters from five feet.
  • Wilson Staff Model MT22 breaks into the top four to continue Wilson’s impressive putter performance for 2023.
  • Cleveland Frontline Elite Elevado wraps up the top five. Another significant showing from Cleveland.

Best Mallet Putters from Five Feet

TOP PICKS: BETTINARDI STUDIO STOCK 16, EVNROLL EV5, LA GOLF MALIBU X

Observations

  • Bettinardi Studio Stock 16 is the best mallet putter from five feet.
  • Evnroll EV5 also excels at five feet, finishing closely behind SS16.
  • LA GOLF Malibu X places third from five feet. If you haven’t seen this product yet, you need to check it out.
  • Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 is fourth. Additionally, it is one of the highest-rated putters by our testing pool for subjective feedback.
  • PXG Battle Ready Hercules ascends to fifth, narrowly beating out the Cleveland Frontline Elite Elevado.

Best Mallet Putters from 10 Feet

TOP PICKS: ODYSSEY TRI-HOT 5K ROSSIE S, TAYLORMADE SPIDER GTX, PXG BATTLE READY BAT ATTACK

Observations

  • Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S dominates from 10 feet. Clearly the best mallet from this distance.
  • TaylorMade Spider GTX takes second place.
  • Last year’s winner, PXG Battle Ready Bat Attack, beats out Wilson Staff Model MT22 for third place.
  • L.A.B Golf Mezz.1 Max rounds out the top five from 10 feet.

Best Mallet Putters from 20 Feet

TOP PICKS: ODYSSEY TRI-HOT 5K ROSSIE S, ODYSSEY WHITE HOT VERSA SEVEN, EVNROLL EV5

Observations

  • Again, Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S trumps the field and places best from 20 feet.
  • Odyssey White Hot Versa Seven adds to Odyssey’s success and takes second place.
  • Evnroll EV5 rounds out the top three.
  • L.A.B. Golf Mezz.1 Max  finishes fourth from 20 feet to cap its impressive mallet putter performance.
  • Inesis HIGH MOI breaks into the top five.

Evnroll EV5 Mallet PutterBest Mallet Putters 2023 – Scores

Best Mallet Putters 2023 Scores

Product NameOverall51020
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie SOdyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S

Check Price
96.6487.8499.5799.59
LAB Golf Mezz.1 MaxL.A.B. Golf MEZZ.1 Max

Check Price
89.6290.7790.4286.01
Evnroll EV5.2 BlackEvnroll EV5

Check Price
89.5798.8285.8488.28
Wilson Staff Model MT22Wilson Staff Model MT22

Check Price
86.7185.6491.5674.70
Cleveland Frontline Elite ElevadoCleveland Frontline Elite Elevado (ALL IN)

Check Price
86.6694.4385.8479.22
TaylorMade Spider GTXTaylorMade Spider GTX

Check Price
86.4889.3492.0567.58
Bettinardi Studio Stock 16Bettinardi SS16

Check Price
85.8699.5586.9865.64
SeeMore M5XSeeMore M5X

Check Price
85.8394.4389.2765.64
Cleveland HB Soft Milled 11Cleveland HB Soft Milled 11 (ALL IN)

Check Price
85.4995.1685.8472.53
PXG Battle Ready HerculesPXG Battle Ready Hercules

Check Price
85.4096.6285.8470.17
Odyssey White Hot Versa SevenOdyssey White Hot Versa Seven

Check Price
84.6294.4375.5497.33
PXG Battle Ready Bat AttackPXG Battle Ready Bat Attack

Check Price
84.4589.3091.5658.85
Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12

Check Price
83.9490.7785.8470.17
SeeMore M5HT OffsetSeeMore M5HT Offset

Check Price
83.2393.7082.4072.43
Zebra AIT1Zebra AIT1

Check Price
83.2190.7786.9863.38
Zebra AIT2Zebra AIT2

Check Price
83.1191.5088.1358.85
Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5

Check Price
82.4497.3680.1170.17
PING MundyPING Mundy

Check Price
82.4292.9681.2672.43
LA Golf Malibu XLA Golf Malibu X

Check Price
82.3498.0981.2665.64
Tour Edge Exotics Wingman 704Tour Edge Exotics Wingman 704

Check Price
81.7787.8482.4072.43
Bettinardi Queen B 14Bettinardi QB14

Check Price
81.3784.9190.4252.06
Tour Edge Exotics Wingman 702Tour Edge Exotics Wingman 702

Check Price
81.3192.2386.9852.06
Vega Golf Merak SMVega Golf Merak SM

Check Price
81.0588.5782.4067.91
Wilson Staff Model TM22Wilson Staff Model TM22

Check Price
79.2986.3889.2743.01
Inesis HIGH MOIInesis High MOI

Check Price
79.2686.3874.3983.75
Indi Golf JettIndi Golf Jett

Check Price
78.5292.2383.5547.53
TaylorMade Spider GTX MaxTaylorMade Spider GTX Max

Check Price
78.1790.0478.9761.11
Mati Putters Gabbo 001Mati Putters Gabbo 001

Check Price
77.5080.5281.2663.38
PING Tyne GPING Tyne G

Check Price
76.0674.6675.5479.22
Indi Golf AllisonIndi Golf Allison

Check Price
73.2988.5773.2554.32
Evnroll EV12Evnroll EV12

Check Price
69.9889.3065.2458.85

Best Mallet Putters 2023 – Buying Considerations

Length

Typically, stock putters come in either 34- or 35-inch lengths. Length can affect distance and direction. Many golfers find they fit better into putters with shorter shafts. Choose a putter that allows for a relaxed setup based on your address posture.

Loft

The right loft promotes a smooth roll off the face. Too little or too much can cause bouncing, hopping and, ultimately, distance control issues. We recommend working with a professional fitter to determine the right loft for your putting stroke.

Best Mallet Putter for Strong Arc

Best Mallet Putter for Strong Arc

Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S stands out as the best mallet putter for strong arc putting strokes. Give it a try. It is our definitive best mallet of 2023.

Blade or Mallet?

Which is best for you? It’s a combination of personal preference and individual putting stroke. While there are few absolutes in fitting, those with a faster putting stroke often are better suited with lighter blade-putter options. If your stroke is slower and smooth, a heavier mallet might be preferable. Mallets offer more forgiveness due to their larger mass properties.

Best Mallet Putter for Slight Arc

Best Mallet Putter for Slight Arc

Evnroll EV5 is a unique offering. With multiple variations available to the consumer, it is our recommendation if you have a slight arc putting stroke.

Toe Hang

As much as tempo is a factor in choosing the right putter, so too is the amount of arc in your stroke. If you open and close the face more than average, consider a heel-shafted putter with more weight in the toe. Balance the putter on your two index fingers. If the putter head hangs with the toe closer to 6 o’clock, it’s toe-balanced. A face-balanced putter will face the sky. Face-balanced putters are generally well suited for golfers with more of a straight-back, straight-through stroke.

Or, you can throw toe hang out the window with L.A.B. Golf. They specialize in fitting using “lie angle balance.” Their putter designs adjust to your appropriate lie angle and assist with returning the club face back to square more consistently.

Lie Angle Balance

Lie Angle Balance

L.A.B. Golf continues to gain momentum. Playing professionals are gaming these putters known for their "Lie Angle Balance" technology. To date, L.A.B. Golf's Mezz.1 Max is the best performing model in our Most Wanted Putter testing. Check it out.

Putter Features

While not quite to the extent of drivers, putters have gone high-tech.

It’s not uncommon to find putters with adjustable weighting which, in addition to changing head weight, can alter toe hang to suit either a stronger or less arcing stroke. Odyssey, Toulon, PXG and Cleveland all feature multi-material putter shafts. LA GOLF and L.A.B. Golf offer composite shaft options. Evnroll and others offer face-milling patterns or inserts designed to not only promote smooth roll but consistent distance (and, in some cases, direction) on mishits.

Fast Versus Slow Greens

Best Mallet for Straight Back-Straight Through

Best Mallet for Straight Back-Straight Through

Cleveland continues to impress with its putter selection. Frontline Elite Elevado is our recommendation if you are a straight back-straight through putting stroke type.

There’s a case to be made for matching the weight of your putter to the speed of the greens you play most often. On slow greens, heavier putters tend to perform better. On fast greens, a delicate touch is needed. Often a lighter putter will produce better results.

Best Mallet Putters 2023 – Product Specs

Best Mallet Putters 2023 Product Specs

ProductLoftLengthSwingweightToe Hang
Bettinardi Queen B 14Bettinardi QB14

Check Price
3.834E 1.4Slight
Bettinardi Studio Stock 16Bettinardi SS16

Check Price
434D 9.5Straight
Cleveland Frontline Elite ElevadoCleveland Frontline Elite Elevado (ALL IN)

Check Price
2.534E 9.3Straight-Strong
Cleveland HB Soft Milled 11Cleveland HB Soft Milled 11 (ALL IN)

Check Price
2.834E 3.3Straight-Strong
Evnroll EV5.2 BlackEvnroll EV5

Check Price
2.434D 9.8Slight-Strong
Evnroll EV12Evnroll EV12

Check Price
3.234E 1.3Straight-Slight
Indi Golf AllisonIndi Golf Allison

Check Price
434D 6.6Straight-Strong
Indi Golf JettIndi Golf Jett

Check Price
434D 8.5Strong
Inesis HIGH MOIInesis High MOI

Check Price
1.534D 2.9Straight
LAB Golf Mezz.1 MaxL.A.B. Golf MEZZ.1 Max

Check Price
4.134E 7.4Lie Angle Balance
LA Golf Malibu XLA Golf Malibu X

Check Price
Descending Loft Technology34D 7.1Slight
Mati Putters Gabbo 001Mati Putters Gabbo 001

Check Price
4.133.5E 8.3Straight
Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie SOdyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S

Check Price
333.75D 4.6Strong
Odyssey White Hot Versa SevenOdyssey White Hot Versa Seven

Check Price
2.434D 5.6Straight
PING MundyPING Mundy

Check Price
3.234D 9.0Straight
PING Tyne GPING Tyne G

Check Price
3.234E 0.3Straight
PXG Battle Ready Bat AttackPXG Battle Ready Bat Attack

Check Price
2.434E 1.9Striaight-Slight-Strong
PXG Battle Ready HerculesPXG Battle Ready Hercules

Check Price
2.834E 9.1Striaight-Slight-Strong
Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5

Check Price
3.633.5D 8.2Slight
Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12

Check Price
433.75D 9.7Straight
SeeMore M5HT OffsetSeeMore M5HT Offset

Check Price
334.25E 7.1Straight
SeeMore M5XSeeMore M5X

Check Price
3.234E 2.6Straight
TaylorMade Spider GTXTaylorMade Spider GTX

Check Price
3.234D 9.9Straight-Sllight
TaylorMade Spider GTX MaxTaylorMade Spider GTX Max

Check Price
2.534D 8.0Straight
Tour Edge Exotics Wingman 702Tour Edge Exotics Wingman 702

Check Price
1.234E 0.7Straight-Slight
Tour Edge Exotics Wingman 704Tour Edge Exotics Wingman 704

Check Price
334E 1.7Straight-Slight
Vega Golf Merak SMVega Golf Merak SM

Check Price
4.234E 8.9Straight
Wilson Staff Model MT22Wilson Staff Model MT22

Check Price
3.334E 1.2Strong
Wilson Staff Model TM22Wilson Staff Model TM22

Check Price
334E 1.2Slight
Zebra AIT1Zebra AIT1

Check Price
1.534D 7.6Straight
Zebra AIT2Zebra AIT2

Check Price
4.234D 7.8Straight

Best Mallet Putters 2023 – Field Notes

During each test, we look for trends that provide insight about market direction as well as what noteworthy changes manufacturers have made to improve year-over-year performance.

L.A.B. Golf Mezz.1 Max Mallet Putter

We are taking a new approach to tester feedback. As always, it will not play a role in our overall rankings. However, subjective feedback from our testing pool allows us to provide more definitive answers regarding sound, feel, looks and likelihood of purchase. Our testing pool now gives a rating on a scale of 1 to 10 for sound, feel, looks and likelihood of purchase.

Sound

Testers' Choice Award - Best for Sound

Testers' Choice Award - Best for Sound

Best for Sound - Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S

  • Odyssey White Hot Versa Seven, Evnroll EV5 and EV12, and Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12 and X 5.5 all rate well for sound.

Feel

Testers' Choice Award - Best for Feel

Testers' Choice Award - Best for Feel

Best for Feel - Evnroll EV5

  • For feel, PXG Battle Ready Bat Attack, Odyssey White Hot Versa Seven, Evnroll EV12 and Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 all rank towards the top.

Looks

Testers' Choice Award - Best for Looks

Testers' Choice Award - Best for Looks

Best for Looks - Odyssey White Hot Versa Seven

  • The highest-ranking mallets for looks are Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K Rossie S, Evnroll EV5 and EV12, Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 and Cleveland HB Soft Milled 11.

Most Likely To Purchase

Testers' Choice Award - Most Likely to Purchase

Testers' Choice Award - Most Likely to Purchase

Most Likely to Purchase - Evnroll EV5

Trends

  • Carrying over from our blade putter test, there are several multi-material and composite shafts showing up in putters across the board. It is still a small percentage but it is increasing year to year. Will we reach an era where the traditional steel putter shaft is the exception? Time will tell.
  • Moveable weighting appears in a few mallet putters this year. It is a putter feature that offers value from a fitting perspective, especially if you play on consistent putting surfaces. Finally moveable weights also help with the stability and can aid in optimizing face rotation on putters to improve accuracy.
  • Grip options have become more varied and while SuperStroke grips often come standard, more companies are using their own company branded grips, or custom grips.
  • Hosel or Neck Options – Several putters in testing have the ability to be purchased with different neck options suited for different putting stokes. Some of these options include slant neck, short slant neck, single bend, double bends and plumbers necks.

Mallet Putters On Putting Green

How We Test

Titleist ProV1 Golf Ball

For Most Wanted Putter testing, we have 20 testers hit eight putts from three different distances: five, 10 and 20 feet. The putter with the fewest total putts is crowned the Best Mallet Putter.

HOW WE TEST - MOST WANTED PUTTER

HOW WE TEST - MOST WANTED PUTTER

The Official Golf Ball of Most Wanted - Titleist ProV1

FAQ

Buying a Mallet Putter

Q: Should I get fitted for a putter?

A: Without a doubt. Don’t just go to the putting corral at your local golf store and choose the putter that feels the best or the one you happen to make a couple of putts with. Do your research, know the facts and take your knowledge to your golf course or store with the intention of being fitted for the right putter for YOUR stroke. Your best chance of finding the best performing putter comes from getting fitted.

Q: How do I find the right length putter for me?

A: Take a comfortable putting stance with a putter. If the putter is too short, it likely it will sit too upright or the heel will be off the ground. If it’s too long, you’ll feel you’re crowding the ball and the toe will be pointing up slightly. Visit a fitter.

Q: What is the price range for a typical putter?

A: Name-brand putters range from $99 to more than $500. Higher-priced models are often 100-per-cent CNC milled but it’s also true that you could be paying a premium for the logo on the putter. Price may always be a factor but don’t assume the best putters are the most expensive.

Most Wanted

Q: How is the Most Wanted Winner determined?

A: Rankings for the Best Mallet Putters 2023 are based on a 100-point scoring system. Putters are scored at five, 10 and 20 feet. The individual scores are then aggregated to arrive at the overall score. Scores are weighted such that the 10-foot score has the greatest influence on the cumulative score.

Q: How were the best putters for stroke type determined?

A: At the beginning of the test, each putter is classified by its toe hang/stroke type. The best within each designation are those that finished highest in overall score with respect to toe hang/stroke type.

Q: How much does subjective feedback like looks, sound and feel factor into your rankings?

A: ZERO. Our rankings are based purely on total putt counts and quantifiable performance metrics. We include subjective notes only because readers have asked for more feedback directly from the testers.

Support Unbiased Testing.

DID YOU KNOW: If only 1% of MyGolfSpy readers donated $25, we would be able to become completely independent in 12-months. With every donation, you create change.

Would you be willing to help by giving a donation? Every dollar will help. Make a donation to support our independent and expert golf equipment research. A PayPal account is not required in order to donate.

Donate to MGS


Amount

Frequency

For You

For You

Partner Content
Feb 22, 2024
What Club Should You Use to Get Up and Down?
adidas tour360 24 adidas tour360 24
Golf Shoes
Feb 22, 2024
adidas TOUR360 24: The Return of an Icon
News
Feb 22, 2024
Opinion: Pro Golfers Should Still Keep Score—But Let’s Reduce the Penalty for an Incorrect Card
MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

Our mission is #ConsumerFirst. We are here to help educate and empower golfers. We want you to get the most out of your money, time and performance. That means providing you with equipment reviews you can trust, as well as honest reporting on the latest issues affecting the game today. #PowerToThePlayer

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

Ball Lab Golf Ball Quality Awards
Jan 22, 2024 | 31 Comments
How Long Does a Round of Golf Take?
Nov 15, 2023 | 0 Comments
MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

Driver Ping G30 Hybrids PXG 0317
3/4 IRON PXG 0311XF 5-GW Srixon Z 565
SW PXG 0317 LW PXG 0311
Putter EVNROLL  
MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy

MyGolfSpy





    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

      Tony P

      3 months ago

      Should there be a separate category for center shafted putters? I didn’t even see these tested

      Reply

      Jim Kenworthy

      9 months ago

      I have looking at mallet putter rankings for 2021, 2022, and 2023. I am surprised not seeing top 5 in following years rankings. Is that because they weren’t tested, the model was discontinued or it just didn’t rank well enough?
      In other words, could the top putter in 2021 be rated in top 5 in 2022 or 2023? Feel that I would like a putter that performs well year after year than a one and done.

      Reply

      Dennis Duncan

      10 months ago

      I Have and Love my SIK putter (now owned by LA Golf). They have the DLT (descending loft technology). I feel that the dlt has helped me hit many more putts solidly.

      Reply

      john

      11 months ago

      Check out the M.O.I. of all of these putters. You’ll find that they don’t EVEN reach 6000. It’s like going to a car dealer and seeing corvettes and stingrays along with other hot looking cars all over the lot. You pick your favorite, sit inside and say this is for me. But when they all have volkswagon engines, what’s the difference? Looks, sound, and the name on them doesn’t mean that the ball will go into the hole with one putter more than another. Without MOI, they’re all looks and no performance!

      Reply

      BeTheBall

      11 months ago

      PING said I was a strong arc putter so I have a heavy toe hang double wide blade putter now BUT I love the look, feel, and results of the new Ping Tomcat 14 face balance putter, how can I have such good results with it in the store everytime I go? Just luck or go for it?

      Reply

      john colette

      11 months ago

      can i get an update on my order

      Reply

      Scott

      11 months ago

      I hate to be the guy who says it, but we’re not going to grow the game with $600 drivers and $400 putters. There’s no way in hell I’ll be able to support my kid if he gets good at golf by high school.

      Reply

      Paul

      11 months ago

      Scott, you are correct. Thee prices are just preposterous at this point.

      Reply

      Hate Tobreakittoya

      11 months ago

      Make more money. Easy solution. Or you could always take up something without equipment like wrestling?

      U-Gruv

      10 months ago

      Wilson Staff Putters – they perform and are half the cost or less. As for drivers & irons, look at good condition used that are 2 years old.

      Reply

      Yaaqob

      12 months ago

      Honestly, surprised the Mizuno putters weren’t included. I tested the vast majority of the included putters when I was getting fitted and the Mizuno ended up being my best fit hands down. The heavier head and feel were incredible.

      Reply

      scott

      12 months ago

      So, the two ball wins the two prior years and you don’t included it in the test…..why? I might assume it’s just to have a new champion but if something wins it needs to be dethroned in a test, not because you used a new metric. Keep up the good work though, you guys are great.

      Reply

      Cody

      12 months ago

      PXG won last year, not the 2-ball.

      Reply

      aburtonky

      2 months ago

      Lately they’re only testing products that came out the current year. It’s why Vokey wedges weren’t tested in 2023 because they were tested in 2022. But they addressed that on social media where they’ll address the current/latest lineup, regardless of the year it was released.

      Reply

      Chris S.

      12 months ago

      Happy to learn that Evnroll has a premium milled, all black mallet with a plumbers neck, I’ve been searching for this setup forever., ordering one immediately. I hope the testers are correct about great feel on this beauty..

      Reply

      Alex

      12 months ago

      Which variation of the Evnroll ev5 did you use for testing? Also, any plans on testing an evnroll putter with the midlock grip?

      Reply

      Alex

      12 months ago

      Which variation of the evnroll ev5 did you guys test? Also any plans on testing an evnroll putter with the midlock grip?

      Reply

      Doug Wenk

      12 months ago

      Curious – from last year the PXG mallet was #1 ranked at 94 this year it comes in at 84. For testing year over year do you do anything to balance it out? Now I do not use the PXG, I use a blade – but curious about the variation year over year and have you thought about it at all?

      Reply

      Wayne

      12 months ago

      It’s almost as if the data is not meaningful. Just because they collect data it doesn’t mean anything…. Results aren’t repeatable. There’s a difference between data and knowledge

      Reply

      Donn Rutkoff

      12 months ago

      I think testing should be grouped : toe hang, or face balanced. I putt with no or virtually no arc. I am only interested in face balanced putters. Does anybody else think that mixing the ‘hang” types all together does not make sense?

      Reply

      Dave P

      12 months ago

      LAB Golf’s Mezz has changed my world – most consistent putter I have ever owned – and I’ve been through a few????

      Reply

      Aces and Birds

      12 months ago

      I have one on the way…Hope my experience is the same!

      Reply

      Daniel

      12 months ago

      Can you explain your scoring system? From 5 feet, is that just the % made? But for the other longer distances, some adder/multiplier? I want to test a few of my putters at home in a similar manner. Thanks!

      Reply

      Gregger

      12 months ago

      I would never buy a putter that was poor 5 feet out. Heck those are the ones I miss the most and if I made them I’d play in the upper 70’s

      Reply

      Kenny

      12 months ago

      Me either. I also don’t understand why putts from 10 feet are weighted more heavily than putts from 5 feet for scoring.

      Reply

      Dave Silkroski

      12 months ago

      No Otey Crissman putter in the mix :-(
      Add an old BullsEye mallet as the baseline! I prefer older over $$$.

      Reply

      Nate

      12 months ago

      You guys should do an article on putter swingweight one of these days. These readings are insane. Some of those putters must feel like sledgehammers.

      Reply

      David

      12 months ago

      Glad you include prior year “Most Wanted” in your pool for reference. However I am surprised the Bat Attack dropped so markedly in the 5ft range from 98.2 (top in 2022) to 89.3 in 2023. Look forward to My Golf Spy results to narrow down equipment choices. Not sure if results that vary this much (20+ ft even more significant) give us enough data to make informed decisions. Supports the suggestion we should all get fitted to find what’s best for us.

      Reply

      Samuel Pearce

      12 months ago

      Interesting that we are supposed to believe that the mallet that won last year is not even in the top 10 best this year yet Tiger Woods still uses the same putter from 20 years ago. If the results between years are not replicable then they are invalidated by the next years test which begs the question are any of them valid. PXG bat attack 1st in 2022, 12th in 2023…

      Reply

      Jarner

      12 months ago

      100% agree! The only thing consistent with these tests are the inconsistent results.. This year we had a bunch of guys who putted the best with this putter. Next year it will be a completely different test group.

      Reply

      AH

      12 months ago

      Completely agree. This is the first time I’ve really gone through the yearly rankings, and given the crazy swings in how an identical putter “performs” in 2022 vs. 2023 I’m not sure why anyone would take them seriously. Really weird to see.

      Reply

      Steve C

      12 months ago

      Glad to see the Most Wanted now includes objective test results as well as subjective tester feedback. Based on reading the entire article the winner looks like the Evnroll EV5 which finished strong on the test results and won Best Slight Arc, Best Feel and Most Likely to Purchase. I look forward to testing the Odyssey Tri Hot 5K Rossie S and the Evnroll EV5. Thanks MGS.

      Reply

      Kyle

      12 months ago

      Gotta love evnroll totally disregarding lefties. At least rightys have a million options and colors too??? come on. at least launch the EV2 and EV5 in lefty at the same time. BRUTAL.

      Reply

      Mark

      12 months ago

      My goodness it must be tough to put 100+ hours of work into this and just get a stream of crying complaints these comment sections have become…

      No their methodology is not perfect and never will be as with any form of research, especially around this topic with hundreds of variables that are nearly impossible to entirely account for. But the golf community is better off having these unbiased reviews as guideposts over nothing at all. As stated in the FAQ, these scores are one input of many that will help you find the best clubs specifically for you, not the end all be all for everyone.

      Anyways, thanks MGS team for the great work as always. Cool to see a LAB putter finally crack the top 3 this year.

      Reply

      Gorman

      12 months ago

      It seems like the criticism is that the scoring seems subjective and random, arguably to the point that it ends up actually *being* biased/misleading without meaning to be.

      Like…how is it possible that 2022’s #1 mallet putter turned into a mediocre pumpkin in 2023 without any changes being made to the putter itself? If something changed about the putter then fine, that is absolutely worth noting. But if it’s just the same putter being scored far lower by different people, that is so random that it’s arguably *worse* than nothing, because it actively misleads people. Seriously: if you’re motivated by this list to try/buy 2023’s “number one putter”…is it actually worth your time, or are their testers going to come back in 2024 and tell you that you spend your money on a piece of garbage? Just makes no sense.

      Reply

      Al

      12 months ago

      Seems like putts made would be the most important criteria and since nobody makes 20 footers that should not weigh in as important as five footers. Great data collection. But most of it is over rated.

      Reply

      don

      12 months ago

      Agreed, fewest total putts from 20′ is kind of silly. From 20’+ making putts has too much luck involved, what we want is inside 2′ tap ins. Inside 5′ all I care about is how many go in.

      Reply

      Kevin

      12 months ago

      Love the article, look forward to it every year. It seems like less and less of these putters are being made available to lefties. I’d love to roll a Rossie S or Evnroll EV12. But alas, they are not available to us… perhaps a lefty only most wanted putter article next year?

      Reply

      Dave R

      12 months ago

      The struggle is real. I love messing around with new putters at the shop, but as a lefty, most of the interesting new models aren’t available. I still try them righty with a left hand low grip, but it’s an ever-present frustration. It’s like trying to find the one left handed desk in a college lecture hall all over again!

      Reply

      Tim Taylor

      12 months ago

      I know you may think the disabled don’t care about golf so you don’t need to worry if your website is accessible to them or not, but they do.! I work in the accessibility field and find that your web site is exceedingly inaccessible! Not only is this relegating us to a second class state, but you are also non-compliant with the American Disabilities Act of 1992. Please take this seriously as the disabled do play golf or want to follow it online. Please let the developer of your web site know that you care about accessibility and get it resolved.

      Thanks!

      Reply

      Ryan

      12 months ago

      Wtf does this even mean? How is posting a public website not including disabled people lol. You obviously figured it out since you commented.

      Reply

      Will

      12 months ago

      I’m surprised the Tommy Armour Impact 3 wasn’t on this list considering how high you’ve rated them before, are these only 2023 putters being tested?

      Reply

      Phillip Bishop

      12 months ago

      Will, thank you for your comment. We’ve made an effort to strictly test the newest products for the corresponding year. Thus, only testing a product if it hasn’t been tested yet or it is a winner from the previous test.

      Reply

      Cody

      12 months ago

      Wow, last year’s overall-winning PXG dropped over 30 points in the 20 foot range. Goes to show how difficult it is to get the same results from one testing pool to the next.

      Reply

      David R

      12 months ago

      So PXG Battle Ready Bat Attack in 2022 got 89. 18 in testing from 20’, but gets 58.85 a year later, something can’t be right there?

      Reply

      Joe K

      12 months ago

      You and I made the same comment at the same time. I was looking to make a move on a new putter this year and was at a PXG store this past weekend and liked the Bat Attack, along with a few blade putters (that surprised me) but was curious how the Bat Attack could score so poorly against itself in two consecutive years.

      Reply

      Tampon Woods

      12 months ago

      Enthusiasm. The testers all knew it was not a new model so they flapped at the putts wit it because they didn’t care as much this time as some of the other new models lol

      Reply

      Joe K

      12 months ago

      The PXG Bat Attack scored much lower in this year’s evaluation than last year. I understand that any given putter’s position might change in the overall ranking based on newer products coming into the market, but I was surprised to see the scores for this putter drop so much this year when compared to itself in last year’s ratings.

      Reply

      Ron McCaslin

      12 months ago

      I cannot believe that the EDEL putters go ZERO consideration in your evaluation. Over the course of almost 50 years I have tried most putters including a lot of earlier models no longer around. I purchased my EAS putter in 2021 and have found it to be the best mallet putter I have ever tried.

      Reply

      Josh

      12 months ago

      That’s weird, I was unaware that Edel had a 2022-2023 release, which would make it pertinent to a 2023 Putter article.

      They must have kept it super low key. That, or it’s not relevant to this discussion because they didn’t actually release one…

      Reply

      Tampon Woods

      12 months ago

      Hehe, snarky, Josh, snarky!!! I love it lol

      Phillip Bishop

      12 months ago

      Ron, Edel did not have a new mallet on the market. We have tested all of their current mallet offerings to date. The same can be said of Mizuno.

      Reply

      Patrick

      12 months ago

      I’ve been using an Odessy mallet putter from a few years back and I really like it. I bought it for better alignment like the two ball Odessy. My only gripe is the toe hang feature which sometimes gets me during those 5 foot putts. I need the accuracy from 20 feet out so, I make a slight adjustment to my stroke for those finishing putts. Odessy putters are on a role the last 5 years.

      Reply

      Gary Sohiosky

      12 months ago

      Where are the Axis 1 Rose putters? Didn’t you test any of them? It would hardly seem fair to exclude them from testing. After watching Justin Rose putt with one of these I’m very surprised more tour players aren’t using one.

      Reply

      SoftRock 66

      12 months ago

      Axis1 has to be the best kept secret in golf. The 2023 Laser shoould have been considered. Otherwise, very informative article!

      Reply

      Ian

      12 months ago

      No value category this year? You guys are losing touch….

      Reply

      Phillip Bishop

      12 months ago

      Ian, we apply a “Best Value” whenever it is applicable. For this particular test, it is not applicable.

      Reply

    Leave A Reply

    required
    required
    required (your email address will not be published)

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Partner Content
    Feb 22, 2024
    What Club Should You Use to Get Up and Down?
    adidas tour360 24 adidas tour360 24
    Golf Shoes
    Feb 22, 2024
    adidas TOUR360 24: The Return of an Icon
    News
    Feb 22, 2024
    Opinion: Pro Golfers Should Still Keep Score—But Let’s Reduce the Penalty for an Incorrect Card