Head to Head: Best Overall Blade Putter vs. Best Value Blade Putter
Buyer's Guides

Head to Head: Best Overall Blade Putter vs. Best Value Blade Putter

Support our Mission. We independently test each product we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

Head to Head: Best Overall Blade Putter vs. Best Value Blade Putter

We’re back to tackle the age-old question, does the price of your putter really matter? Should you spend an extra $200 for top-tier performance, or can a budget-friendly option help you sink just as many putts? To find out, we put our best overall blade putter, the Evnroll Neo Classic ER2, against the best value blade putter, the Cleveland HB Soft 2 #1. Without giving too much away, if you’re a value-conscious golfer, you may have just discovered one of the smartest deals of 2024.

Putt Distance Five Feet

When testing the best blade putters, we evaluate performance from five feet, 10 feet, and 20 feet. Scores are weighted with 55% for 10-foot putts, 25% for five-foot putts, and 20% for 20-foot putts. This method ensures that our results for the best golf putters of 2024 are those that are most likely to perform when a one-putt is needed.

The Evnroll Neo Classic ER2 was the best overall putter from five feet. It scored a perfect 10/10 from this distance. Golfers who struggle with shorter putts will want something as solid and stable as the Evnroll. For 60% of the testing pool, the Evnroll Neo Classic ER2 was the best putter from five feet.

The Cleveland HB Soft 2 #1 finished more in the middle of the pack with a score of 8/10. It won’t be your most reliable choice for the short ones.

Putt Distance 10 Feet

If you look at the 5-foot putts as the need to make, the 10-foot is more of the nice to make putts. The more of these you can drain, the easier it is to get up and down, lower your score, etc.
From 10 feet, Evnroll scored 8.9 compared to Cleveland’s 8.1.

We tested a total of 39 putters in this 2024 test. The Evnroll’s score of 8.9 leaves it in a tie for the third-best putter from 10 feet.

Cleveland is tied for 4th.

Both putters held their own from 10 feet in a competitive putter test. The best putter from 10 feet is the T-Squared Putters TS-912.

Putt Distance 20 Feet

At this point, you should have a pretty good idea of how the Evnroll putter earned top honors in this 2024 blade putter testing. With a first-place finish from five feet and third place from 10 feet, it must be amazing from 20 feet, right?

Not quite.

The results from 20 feet explain exactly why we test putters from three different distances.

The Evnroll scores 7.1/10 from 20 feet and fell well outside the top 10 from this distance.

Cleveland, on the other hand, finished first place overall from 20 feet with a score of 9.8/10. If you need help with your lag putting more than the knee knockers, the Cleveland is a smart choice.

Value

Now, here’s where things get interesting. The Evnroll ER2 costs $399, and the Cleveland HB Soft costs $149. It’s a $250 difference.

From a performance standpoint, the Evnroll finished first overall and the Cleveland sixth. The Evnroll’s consistency and accuracy are definite advantages, especially on putts 10 feet and under.

Cleveland did well at 20 feet and hung in there during the 10-foot performance. However, the feel, look, and overall design of the Cleveland and Evnroll putters obviously differ.

The Bottom Line

Go get fitted and see which one works best for you.

The most important thing to take away here is that performance and price don’t always go hand in hand. While the Cleveland wasn’t the cheapest putter in the 2024 test, it still is a very fair price considering its performance. Don’t turn away a less expensive putter simply because it’s less expensive.

Evnroll vs Cleveland: Which is right for you?

Who’s it For?

You value making putts from five feet: The Evnroll Neo Classic ER2 had the best performance from five feet.

You want more consistency from 10 feet. Although not a first-place finish, the Evnroll Neo Classic ER2 had a third-place finish from 10 feet.

Who’s it not for?

❌Golfers who struggle with lag putting.

❌ Anyone on a budget.

Who’s it For?

✅ You need to make more putts from 20 feet. For any golfer who struggles with lag putting, the Cleveland HB Soft 2 #1 is the best choice.

You are on a budget but don’t want to sacrifice performance. The Cleveland HB Soft 2 #1 is high-performing and only costs $149.

Who’s it not for?

❌ Players that struggle from five feet and under.

❌ Anyone who needs a specific hosel type should know that the Cleveland HB Soft 2 #1 only comes with a plumber’s neck hosel.

img

MyGolfSpy Testing Toolkit

World-class testing requires world-class equipment. This is the gear we trust to help us fulfill our Most Wanted testing.

For You

For You

First Look
Nov 13, 2024
The Big Mac of Golf Bags? Let Me Explain!
Jordan golf shoes Jordan golf shoes
Golf Shoes
Nov 13, 2024
Every Jordan Golf Shoe Ranked
Golf Shoes
Nov 13, 2024
Golf Shoe Deals of the Week
Staff

Staff

Staff

We are independent, unbiased and always put the #ConsumerFirst. We spend thousands of hours testing and researching products to help you get the most out of your game. This way you can be sure you have reviews you can trust.

Staff

Staff

Staff

PGA/LPGA/LIV Top Money Earners of 2024
Nov 8, 2024 | 7 Comments
10 Unique Golf Gifts 2024
Oct 31, 2024 | 2 Comments
Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff





    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

      Matt

      2 months ago

      “From 10 feet, Evnroll scored 8.9 compared to Cleveland’s 8.1.”

      What does this even mean? How tangible is this? What value does 0.8 add to a person looking to improve putting inside 10-ft.

      Reply

      Rick

      2 months ago

      That Evnroll seems closer to a mallet than a blade, Cleveland looks much more blade like.

      Reply

      Steve P

      2 months ago

      “Cleveland did well at 20 feet…” Understatement of the year! it blew the doors off the competition from 20 feet and was decent from the other 2 lengths. Add some lead tape to the Cleveland putter and you’ll make more short putts and save yourself $250!

      Reply

      Aaron

      2 months ago

      Great read, how about a mallet comparison?

      Reply

      Alan

      2 months ago

      I bought the Evnroll a few weeks ago and love it. It’s so stable for short to medium putts. I’ve had a few strange long putts though. Tend to push them

      Reply

      Jeff

      2 months ago

      I would think from 5 ft skill would override any differences in putters. I did not see how you tested, real people or a machine, so the results are hard to apply. A really good putter can make 10 or 10 with a Cashin, and a bad putter miss 10 with the best putter on the planet. Hell man, George Low could putt with his feet better than you.

      Reply

    Leave A Reply

    required
    required
    required (your email address will not be published)

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    First Look
    Nov 13, 2024
    The Big Mac of Golf Bags? Let Me Explain!
    Jordan golf shoes Jordan golf shoes
    Golf Shoes
    Nov 13, 2024
    Every Jordan Golf Shoe Ranked
    Golf Shoes
    Nov 13, 2024
    Golf Shoe Deals of the Week