Shopping for Golf Shoes? Don’t Make This Mistake
Golf Shoes

Shopping for Golf Shoes? Don’t Make This Mistake

Support our Mission. We independently test each product we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

Shopping for Golf Shoes? Don’t Make This Mistake

Shopping for new golf gear can feel as daunting as hitting a tee shot after the slow foursome in front lets you play through.

But it doesn’t have to be.

I’ve bought, tested and worn well over 100 golf shoes, and have learned a thing or two about what makes some inherently better than the rest. Unfortunately, there are also few pitfalls that you MUST avoid if you want to end up with something that isn’t a waste of your time and money.

There are loads of things you should avoid. Don’t buy without trying on and definitely don’t buy something online unless there is a liberal return policy.

But the biggest mistake I see golfers make is far less obvious.

Are you shopping for new golf shoes? Don’t make this mistake.

Don’t stick with one brand

We’re big advocates of being your own brand. Rarely, if ever, is a full bag of clubs from one brand the best for your game. The same goes for golf shoes.

Just because you’ve worn FootJoy your entire life doesn’t mean it’s the end-all and be-all of golf shoes. Just because you’re a NIKE loyalist doesn’t mean you shouldn’t broaden your horizons and try something outside of the Swoosh’s influence.

I have yet to find one brand that makes both the best spikeless and spiked golf shoes. In fact, very rarely does a brand have more than one or two top performers in their entire lineup. Before you settle on one brand for the rest of your life, take time to explore the other options.

I know, it’s tempting to find something you like and stick with it. But more often that not, branching out to try something new can result in an even better golfing experience.

It’s not dissimilar to that favorite dive you’re a regular at. While it’s comforting (and easy) to order the same thing time and time again, you’re doing yourself a disservice by not at least exploring other options.

You never know what you could be missing out on.

So try those PUMAs. Give some leeway to a newer brand like PAYNTR. Ditch the ECCOs in favor of something from Under Armour. What have you got to lose?

All that’s left to gain is a new favorite pair of golf shoes. You’re welcome.

For You

For You

We Tried It
Oct 3, 2024
This Rangefinder is Unique!
FootJoy Pro/SLX BOA golf shoes FootJoy Pro/SLX BOA golf shoes
News
Oct 3, 2024
4 Tips to Extend the Lifespan of Your Golf Shoes
Uncategorized
Oct 3, 2024
Best Funny Golf Gifts
Connor Lindeman

Connor Lindeman

Connor Lindeman

Connor is MyGolfSpy's resident sneakerhead who believes that golf is more enjoyable with a fresh pair of kicks. When he isn't scrolling Twitter to find his next golf shoe purchase, you can find him at the piano or trying a new dessert place with his wife. #Lefty

Connor Lindeman

Connor Lindeman

Connor Lindeman

Connor Lindeman

Connor Lindeman





    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

      Greg

      4 weeks ago

      Footjoy have fitted my dodgy feet very well over the years, but now they have stopped making most of their shoes in a M fitting, I have had to look elsewhere. I am about to try a pair of Sketchers.

      Reply

      Jim

      4 weeks ago

      When shoe soles start to come off, glue them. Clean the area with auto brake cleaner and only use Seal-All to glue them. All other glue is trash.

      Reply

      Jack Dolman

      4 weeks ago

      I have a neuroma in my right foot. Consequently I wear shoes that have a more supportive sole. Flip between FootJoy and GFore. Nice style and if you wait for sales pretty affordable.

      Reply

      Kuso

      1 month ago

      Don’t buy spikeless, no matter what anybody tells you.

      Reply

      Frank

      4 weeks ago

      I only buy spikeless. You lose some traction but I feel they are more comfortable and that is what is most important to me. And comfortable shoes are the most important thing if you walk as opposed to you riders. And I also think that if you find a brand that fits you best to run with them. That brand for me is Ecco.

      Reply

      ctg44

      4 weeks ago

      Stability is more important to my feet than softness, even when I walk. I wear Sqairz and use hockey insoles in them to ensure my feet are fully supported. They are NOT soft, but my feet never hurt no matter how many holes I walk. Equating soft and squishy shoes with comfort is a bad premise, and it’s been proven time and again that stability is key for your golf swing (unless you are as consistent as Scottie Scheffler, and you are not).

      Steve

      4 weeks ago

      It has been studied and proven that people with bad knees should only use spikeless because spikes don’t allow as much movement in the violent downswing and follow through. I only use spikeless because of this.

      Reply

      Frizmoz

      4 weeks ago

      Sometimes it’s better to say nothing, rather than confirm beyond all reasonable doubt…

      Reply

      Dave R

      4 weeks ago

      I’ve had some great spikeless shoes. You do need to check the sole for aggressive treads and not soft bumps, especially for dewy or wet days.

      I’m walker and some spiked shoes are too stiff for walking 18 holes.

      Reply

      Peter R

      1 month ago

      I am constantly trying new brands because I have hard to fit feet. Some have been OK. Gave up on New Balance. Have bought skechers and Etonic and they were OK but wore them out. Footjoy OK but hard to find in Widths. Just ordered a new brand called Fitwell which claims to have extra room in the front where I need it. We’ll see….THeir customer service is Chinese and did not know how to read the email I sent them asking for more information about the cleats (they claim replaceable). I wanted to know what style the cleats were and are they easily available. COULD NOT GET A STRAIGHT ANSWER….trying the shoes anyway because I need new shoes!

      Reply

      Frank

      4 weeks ago

      I don’t know if you have tried Ecco but they have a removable insert if you have wider feet.

      Reply

      ctg44

      4 weeks ago

      Try Sqairz. Not the prettiest shoe, but really comfortable. I have a VERY hard to fit foot, with a heel area about as wide as that of a thin teenage supermodel and the forefoot area as wide as the average sasquatch. It’s just the stupidest foot shape in the world, and I put the Sqairz on in a size down from my normal running shoes and swapped the insoles to something a little firmer with more support and boom…best golf shoes EVER!

      Reply

      Mike

      4 weeks ago

      True Linkswear has zero drop wide toe box golf shoes that are awesome. I have 3 pairs and I can walk 36 at the age of 55.

      Reply

      D Lee

      1 month ago

      Different brands may have their own unique last i.e. particular shoe shape that may fit you the best. That’s one reason to stay with one brand.

      Reply

      Mike Meyers

      1 month ago

      Interesting article and duly noted. I’ve been using ECCO shoes for a while, but as a senior who now requires an orthotic insert I’m going to be shopping for something new. The ECCOs are just too ‘small’ inside. Is that something that can be measured?

      Reply

      David Bramuchi

      1 month ago

      I am 79 and have tried several brands of golf shoes. I stick with FJ they just fit me properly. I am a traditionalist and actually can’t stand the golf shoes that look like tennis shoes, I don’t do spikeless either. I like the leather shoes, do not like the fabric shoes. Don’t like the shoes that the rear comes up the back of your foot. Asethetically speaking that looks stupid and provides nothing. I have about 15 pair of FJ’s and rotate them for each round. I thoroughly clean the shoes and the soft spikes after each round. The new FJ’s I think are stupid looking and I do not have any of those either and never will. All the shoes I have are Dryjoys. Just can’t stand the look of the new type of shoes being made by most all of the manufatrures. Sticking with what I got.

      Reply

      Rob

      1 month ago

      David we sound just alike in our opinion of what Golf she looks like versus shoes that look like they’re from Mars. We are getting old and we are opinionated and probably FJ‘s worst nightmare because we have too many shoes. I rotated five pair and they were kept in the original boxes undertemperature controlled conditions some of my shoes separated after very little wear and were out of warranty and not supported by FJ. Sell some Temperature controlled conditions some of my shoes separated after very little wear and we’re out of warranty and not supported by FJ. Sell some of your shoes before they get old in the box .

      Reply

      Dr Tee

      1 month ago

      I disagree–once you find a brand, model or line and a last that fits your foot and suits your game and style (walking vs riding) stay with it !! (I apply the same rule to ski boots as well). Companies tend to stay with the same lasts year after year. My go to shoes for years have been TRUE-bedroom slipper fit right out of the box-designed by pro golfer Ryan Moore and his brother. No question returns policy.

      Reply

      Chuck Zirkle

      1 month ago

      I have tried a few other brands when I started playing golf in 1985, but settled on FootJoy. I find that their last and fit runs true throughout their styles. Not all brands sizing run the same, speaking from personal experiences. Sizes can differ from brand to brand. I want a golf shoe that will hold up and FJ does that for me. Whenever I order a 12W from FJ, I know I can take it out of the box and play 18 holes without having to worry. Première and Tradition are my go to shoes now. Still playing FootJoy DryJoy Tours (MyJoys) shoes, in that they last when properly cared for. Sorry that FJ dropped that line. My take is if you find a shoe that works, stick with it. Your feet will thank you. I had a serious issue with Plantar Fasciitis, with inserts prescribed by my doctor, I was able to get through PF, walk and play golf and have not had an issue with it since. FJ shoes provided me the solid foundation, flexibility and correct fit, I needed. And it only took about six months. My mother always bought us good shoes growing up, and by brand name, and she stood by one brand. Said you will not have problems with you feet if you buy good shoes. You know your momma can’t always be wrong. My two cents worth.

      Reply

    Leave A Reply

    required
    required
    required (your email address will not be published)

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    We Tried It
    Oct 3, 2024
    This Rangefinder is Unique!
    FootJoy Pro/SLX BOA golf shoes FootJoy Pro/SLX BOA golf shoes
    News
    Oct 3, 2024
    4 Tips to Extend the Lifespan of Your Golf Shoes
    Uncategorized
    Oct 3, 2024
    Best Funny Golf Gifts